A roadmap renders as the forward section of a pull request description

actor

The author of a pull request description, and the owner reading it.

problem

A description's forward section is written by hand from plan files and recipe answers, so it drifts from the roadmap and the Specs it names.

outcome

Render a roadmap's entries, what waits on the owner and the deferred questions as Markdown a pull request description carries as its forward section, so the plan a description proposes is the roadmap the graph holds.

rule.memoRecipe line 26 · specs/consumers/roadmap.memo.sdp.md:26

Recipe 55 renders one roadmap's reading, recipe 53's answer for that Pack, as one Markdown memo a pull request description carries as its forward section; the roadmap page shows the same bytes.

no example exercises it

rule.sections line 27 · specs/consumers/roadmap.memo.sdp.md:27

The memo holds, in order: the roadmap's title, a line saying what to state and built mean, and its framing; the entries to design, to state and to build, each need in priority order with every entry's place; what waits on the owner; the questions that name no decider; the entries built and still listed; the unresolved members with their original places and ids; and the deferred open questions with their triggers. The to design and to build sections always appear and say when they hold no entry; every other section is left out when it holds no row.

no example exercises it

rule.purposeAndReach line 28 · specs/consumers/roadmap.memo.sdp.md:28

An entry's purpose and reach is read, never authored: its intent's problem, or its outcome when it states no problem, then how many Specs outside its scope wait on it and how many of its parts are ready to build now. These values state its purpose and its place in the graph's structure, never why the owner selected the entry or gave it its place; the description's author may state that reason around the memo, and the memo adds no status, date, estimate or assignment to a pull request.

no example exercises it

rule.holds line 29 · specs/consumers/roadmap.memo.sdp.md:29

An entry to design names the parts that set its need, its own first, each with its stated next rung and the clauses and dependency targets that hold it, then its blocking questions and its decisions below ready; an entry to state names the waiting statements the statement queue puts before its own, inside the entry, elsewhere on the roadmap and outside it, as advice on the order of statements and never as a readiness requirement; an entry to build names each Spec it rests on that is not built.

no example exercises it

rule.authorsOwn line 30 · specs/consumers/roadmap.memo.sdp.md:30

The memo derives no reason for the priority and carries no re-entry condition or refused list; the description's author writes those around it.

no example exercises it

rule.readingOrderNoted line 31 · specs/consumers/roadmap.memo.sdp.md:31

A memo of a Pack whose order is reading order says so under the framing, so no description presents it as a priority.

no example exercises it

rule.deterministic line 32 · specs/consumers/roadmap.memo.sdp.md:32

One graph and one set of parameters render one memo, byte for byte.

no example exercises it

0 unkeyed rules.

memoRecipe line 36 · specs/consumers/roadmap.memo.sdp.md:36

recipe 55, the roadmap memo, takes params.pack and params.decider as recipe 53 does; without pack it reads the one Pack whose manifest states order: priority, and with none or several it returns { diagnostics: [{ parameter, problem }], memo: null }; otherwise it answers { diagnostics: [], memo }, the memo one string.

memoHead line 37 · specs/consumers/roadmap.memo.sdp.md:37

the memo opens with the line ## The next work, from the roadmap, a blank line, the line Roadmap: followed by the Pack's title and its id as a code span, a blank line, the line To state means the floor allows ready and a person still judges the statement. Built means every Spec of the entry's work states ready and has an implementation binding; it reports no passing test and no deployment. and a blank line, each paragraph of the framing as authored followed by a blank line, and for a reading-order Pack the line This Pack's order is reading order, not a stated priority. and a blank line.

Cited at

• test/recipes.test.ts:8384

memoDesign line 38 · specs/consumers/roadmap.memo.sdp.md:38

the section ### To design holds a table with the columns Place, Entry, Next and Purpose and reach; Next reads, for at most three of the work rows with the entry's need, the entry's own first and the rest in Spec-id order, the row's id as a code span or itself for the entry's own, its stated rung and stated next rung as code spans joined by → , then held by and each clause id followed by its targets as code spans in parentheses, or nothing holds it; then and <n> more parts to design when rows are left out; then blocked by and each blocking question's address as a code span, or its Spec id when unkeyed; then decided by and each decision below ready as a code span with its stated rung; the parts joined by ; .

Cited at

• test/recipes.test.ts:8385

memoState line 39 · specs/consumers/roadmap.memo.sdp.md:39

the section ### To state holds a table with the columns Place, Entry, Earlier waiting statements and Purpose and reach; the third column reads No preceding waiting statement in the statement queue. when the entry's earlierStatements is empty, and otherwise in this entry followed by those inside it as code spans, on the roadmap followed by those at another entry as code spans each with (place <n>), and <n> outside the roadmap, each part present only when it holds a row and the parts joined by ; .

Cited at

• test/recipes.test.ts:8386

memoBuild line 40 · specs/consumers/roadmap.memo.sdp.md:40

the section ### To build holds a table with the columns Place, Entry, Purpose and reach and Rests on; Rests on lists each Spec the entry rests on as a code span with its need, or reads nothing unbuilt.

Cited at

• test/recipes.test.ts:8387

memoEntry line 41 · specs/consumers/roadmap.memo.sdp.md:41

an Entry cell is the entry's title followed by its id as a code span; the Purpose and reach cell is the intent line, ending with a full stop when it ends with none, then Waited on by <n>. when Specs wait on it and <n> of its parts ready to build now. for an entry not to build that has such parts.

memoWaiting line 42 · specs/consumers/roadmap.memo.sdp.md:42

the section ### Waiting on the <decider> lists one line per row of recipe 53's waiting.questions and waiting.statements, questions first and statements in the order the answer gives: a question as its address as a code span, or its Spec id when unkeyed, (blocking) when it blocks, place and the places, and its text; a statement as State , the Spec id as a code span, its stated rung and the rung its floor allows, and the places.

Cited at

• test/recipes.test.ts:8388

memoUndecided line 43 · specs/consumers/roadmap.memo.sdp.md:43

the section ### Questions without a decider opens with the line These questions have no named decider. and a blank line, then lists one line per row of recipe 53's waiting.withoutDecider: its address as a code span, or its Spec id as a code span followed by question and its authored position from 1 when unkeyed, then (blocking) when it blocks, place and the places; the text stays on the roadmap page, so a corpus with many such questions keeps a short memo.

memoBuilt line 44 · specs/consumers/roadmap.memo.sdp.md:44

the section ### Built and still on the roadmap lists each built entry as its place, its title and its id as a code span. The section ### Unresolved members follows when recipe 53 reports unresolved members, listing each as - Place <place>: <id>, the id as a code span.

memoDeferred line 45 · specs/consumers/roadmap.memo.sdp.md:45

the section ### Deferred, with their triggers lists each open question recipe 20 marks as a deferral, in the register's order, as its address as a code span, or its Spec id when unkeyed, its text, and Trigger: with its trigger.

memoMarkup line 46 · specs/consumers/roadmap.memo.sdp.md:46

code spans follow the proposal memo's rule; outside code spans, authored <, > and & are written as <, > and &, respectively; other authored text is written verbatim, with each line break written as a space and, inside a table cell, each | written \|; every line ends with a line feed and the memo with one.

Verifier bindings

• test:protocol.roadmap-memo-recipe · anchored · test anchor binding present · test/roadmap.test.ts:39

  External run evidence from test/roadmap.test.ts

  Test anchors: test:protocol.roadmap-memo-recipe, test:protocol.roadmap-recipe. Specs verified by those bindings: spec:consumers.roadmap, spec:consumers.roadmap.memo.

  Run 1: external run evidence from vitest 4.1.10

  Build: CI 391 · Branch: cursor/media-plan-and-articles-09b1 · Commit: 076cd4f1f85640d8236e5cca1bffffa68ab79a33 · Start: 2026-10-31T15:32:20.471Z · Stop: 2026-10-31T15:34:02.073Z

  Name	Suite	Result	Duration
  keeps manifest places and reports an unresolved middle member	the roadmap recipes	passed	38.1 ms
  escapes HTML outside code spans in memo titles and framing	the roadmap recipes	passed	5.44 ms
  reads the work's need: 'is ready and implemented throughout'	the roadmap recipes	passed	20.1 ms
  reads the work's need: 'has one part ready and not implemented'	the roadmap recipes	passed	9.72 ms
  reads the work's need: 'has one part below ready whose floor …'	the roadmap recipes	passed	7.15 ms
  reads the work's need: 'has one part below ready whose floor …'	the roadmap recipes	passed	14.65 ms
  reads the work's need: 'has one part implemented below ready'	the roadmap recipes	passed	13 ms
  reads the work's need: 'has a ready root and one descendant w…'	the roadmap recipes	passed	6.1 ms
  reads the work's need: 'has a ready root and one descendant h…'	the roadmap recipes	passed	9.38 ms
  reads the work's need: 'has one descendant that also refines …'	the roadmap recipes	passed	8.17 ms
  selects priority Packs in id order and reads an explicitly named ordinary Pack	the roadmap recipes	passed	17.93 ms
  names holding parts and a descendant's outside parent	the roadmap recipes	passed	24.05 ms
  renders each unbuilt dependency once when two relations reach it	the roadmap recipes	passed	9.95 ms
  lists sorted incoming relations, Pack memberships and dependency places	the roadmap recipes	passed	13.87 ms
  includes keyed and unkeyed blocking questions on shaping decisions	the roadmap recipes	passed	9.19 ms
  finds earlier statements through a shaping decision's own waiting statement	the roadmap recipes	passed	4.22 ms
  ends the intent line with a full stop: A purpose?	the roadmap recipes	passed	3.05 ms
  ends the intent line with a full stop: A purpose!	the roadmap recipes	passed	2.43 ms
  ends the intent line with a full stop: A purpose	the roadmap recipes	passed	2.45 ms
  ends the intent line with a full stop: A purpose.	the roadmap recipes	passed	2.65 ms
  keeps queue order across places, including earlier statements inside, elsewhere and outside	the roadmap recipes	passed	7.51 ms
  deduplicates shared descendants, preserves places, and lists decision entries apart	the roadmap recipes	passed	6.16 ms
  lists every unassigned question apart, including unkeyed and shared shaping decisions	the roadmap recipes	passed	7.14 ms
  pins memo bytes, intent fallback, line breaks and table escaping	the roadmap recipes	passed	8.9 ms
  pins every populated memo section byte for byte	the roadmap recipes	passed	23.61 ms
  pins empty design and build sections byte for byte	the roadmap recipes	passed	5.75 ms
  reads purpose from intent and counts distinct waiting Specs and buildable parts	the roadmap recipes	passed	22.83 ms

• test:protocol.studio-roadmap-page · anchored · test anchor binding present · test/studio-roadmap.test.ts:24

  External run evidence from test/studio-roadmap.test.ts

  Test anchors: test:protocol.studio-roadmap-page. Specs verified by those bindings: spec:consumers.roadmap.memo, spec:consumers.spec-studio.navigation, spec:consumers.spec-studio.roadmap-page.

  Run 1: external run evidence from vitest 4.1.10

  Build: CI 391 · Branch: cursor/media-plan-and-articles-09b1 · Commit: 076cd4f1f85640d8236e5cca1bffffa68ab79a33 · Start: 2026-10-31T15:32:20.471Z · Stop: 2026-10-31T15:34:02.073Z

  Name	Suite	Result	Duration
  shows unresolved members with their original manifest places	Studio roadmap page	passed	31.36 ms
  publishes the empty state and navigation even with no roadmap	Studio roadmap page	passed	16.43 ms
  renders the board, four need lists, numbered gaps, legend and entries listed apart	Studio roadmap page	passed	0.94 ms
  counts empty board columns and gives each empty need list its own sentence	Studio roadmap page	passed	25.86 ms
  shows holding parts and their next-rung clauses: has one part implemented below ready	Studio roadmap page	passed	26.69 ms
  shows holding parts and their next-rung clauses: has a ready root and one descendant held by a blocking question	Studio roadmap page	passed	16.98 ms
  shows holding parts and their next-rung clauses: has one descendant that also refines a Spec outside the roadmap	Studio roadmap page	passed	28.01 ms
  keeps waiting questions, provisional readings, unnamed deciders and statements in recipe order	Studio roadmap page	passed	3.58 ms
  leaves out Earlier statements when no waiting statement precedes the entry	Studio roadmap page	passed	24.36 ms
  uses the correct statement count and verb for 0 waiting statements	Studio roadmap page	passed	18.36 ms
  uses the correct statement count and verb for 1 waiting statements	Studio roadmap page	passed	22.88 ms
  uses the correct statement count and verb for 2 waiting statements	Studio roadmap page	passed	25.07 ms
  renders code spans and escapes authored titles consistently on the board and entry	Studio roadmap page	passed	19.89 ms
  shows decisions and their questions, dependency folds, incoming work and other Packs	Studio roadmap page	passed	62.18 ms
  labels an ordinary Pack answer as authored reading order	Studio roadmap page	passed	30.08 ms
  uses each roadmap's escaped page name for every local entry link and copies recipe 55's exact bytes	Studio roadmap page	passed	73.4 ms
  shows every row without script and supplies the existing filter with need tokens	Studio roadmap page	passed	1.22 ms
  keeps heading, memo and entry ids distinct when roadmap names contain their suffixes	Studio roadmap page	passed	38.68 ms
  stacks the board at phone width using the Studio breakpoint	Studio roadmap page	passed	0.38 ms

Requirement drawing

• Declared verifying examples: no declared verifying example.

Decisions

No decision record named.

• component:protocol.projections · read-only output, layout and owned publication · src/projections/design-review.ts:29 · layer edge · context protocol

  Uses

  • component:protocol.extract · the carrier and source pipeline · src/extract/index.ts:192 · layer application · context protocol
  • component:protocol.graph · the one graph and its semantic decisions · src/graph/schema.ts:34 · layer domain · context protocol
  • component:protocol.model · the authored contracts and stable ids · src/model/anchors.ts:100 · layer domain · context protocol
  • component:protocol.notation · the leaf step codec · src/notation/slots.ts:261 · layer domain · context protocol
  • component:protocol.reader · the typed graph contract and body evaluator · src/reader/reader.ts:671 · layer application · context protocol
  • component:protocol.validate · one finding currency and ordered checks · src/validate/validators.ts:72 · layer domain · context protocol
• impl:protocol.roadmap-memo-recipe · realizes the roadmap memo in the shipped recipe catalog · test/roadmap.test.ts:27

  Uses

  None.

• impl:protocol.studio-roadmap-page · renders roadmap needs, holding parts and the shared Markdown memo · src/projections/studio/pages/roadmap-page.ts:168

  Component: component:protocol.projections · read-only output, layout and owned publication · src/projections/design-review.ts:29 · layer edge · context protocol

  Uses

  None.

Runtime observation: not tracked.

Runtime observation: not tracked.

Build attestations: not tracked.

Deployments: not tracked.

Bills of materials: not tracked.