Spec Studio

An authored relation may carry its reason

spec:model.relation-reasonsBusiness Rule · storyready floor ready

Packs: pack:design-iteration-v1, pack:design-management-v1, pack:self-hosting-v1

Design: 5 design entries · no pinned declarations · 1 decision

Findings: no errors, no warnings

specs/model/relation-reasons.sdp.md

No open questions and no blocking questions; implementation binding present, verifier binding present, and expected-outcome oracle none.

The original design let a relation say why it holds: a rationale on refines, a strength on dependsOn, an aspect on constrainedBy and a reason on supersedes (docs/lineage/v0-design/01-core-primitives.md §4; 04-authoring-surfaces.md §1.3). The Protocol's relations carry a type, a target and a claim; a relation without a reason leaves the explanation of why a Spec rests on another in narrative prose a reader has to find. The prose-ownership decision gives free prose a typed owner; this Spec gives a relation's reason its home on that relation.

The first adopter meets the reverse case. When its mention audit reported Spec pairs named in prose with no relation behind them, it declared the relations that were missing dependencies and kept the rest as prose, each listed with a one-line reason no typed relation fits (libar-platform/docs/feedback/sdp-feedback-01.md, "The mention warnings were mostly missing edges"; libar-platform/design/tools/prose-mentions.json). A reason on a relation says why an edge holds; a listed mention reason says why none does.

Intent
problem
A reviewer reading a relation cannot see why it holds, and a reviewer reading a mention left as prose cannot tell an intended pointer from a forgotten dependency without a list kept outside the graph.
outcome
Let an author say in one line why a Spec refines, depends on, is constrained by, is decided by or supersedes another, beside the relation itself.
Rule
rule line 23 · specs/model/relation-reasons.sdp.md:23
An authored relation may carry one optional reason, a single line of prose owned by that relation from that Spec to that target.
rule line 24 · specs/model/relation-reasons.sdp.md:24
One optional reason serves every relation type. No strength, aspect or other attribute rides a relation, except the rule keys an example's verifies lists, which the rule-coverage recipe reads.
rule line 25 · specs/model/relation-reasons.sdp.md:25
A reason is intent, as its relation is; it confers no delivery fact, moves no readiness floor and changes nothing its edge confers, and a relation without one stays lawful.
rule line 26 · specs/model/relation-reasons.sdp.md:26
In the envelope a relation target is a plain Spec id or an object with target and optional reason; a declared verifies object may also carry exercises. A target-only object reads as the plain id, plain ids and objects may mix in one relation, and no target is written twice. The TypeScript carrier passes the same reason beside the target.
rule line 27 · specs/model/relation-reasons.sdp.md:27
A reason on supersedes says what the newer decision replaces, and a reason on a refines from one decision to another says which part of the older decision the newer one narrows.
rule line 28 · specs/model/relation-reasons.sdp.md:28
A reason reaches readers with its relation through the graph, so a projection or a recipe reads it from the edge and never from the carrier.
rule line 29 · specs/model/relation-reasons.sdp.md:29
A mention left as prose carries no reason in the Spec. A corpus may keep the mentions it intends as rows of from, to and reason beside its Specs and pass them to the mention audit as a parameter; the audit reports the pairs a row matches apart from the rest, each with its reason, and lists the rows that match no current pair, while the validator reads no such list and its warning stands.

7 unkeyed rules.

Design
envelopeTarget line 33 · specs/model/relation-reasons.sdp.md:33
a relation target is a Spec id or { target: <spec id>, reason: <one line> }, the two mixing in one list and a single target taking either form; a declared verifies object may also carry exercises, and an object with another key, an empty reason, or a reason on two lines is refused; an object carrying only target reads as the plain id.
builderArgument line 34 · specs/model/relation-reasons.sdp.md:34
each TypeScript relation builder takes an optional second argument, dependsOn(target, { reason }), with verifies(target, { reason, exercises }) also taking the rule keys, and a builder called without it writes a plain declared relation.
edgeReason line 35 · specs/model/relation-reasons.sdp.md:35
an authored graph edge carries an optional reason, and the reader's relation ends carry it; the guarantees recipe (3), dependency footing (21), the planning slice (19) and the decision register (31) show it beside the relation.
gherkinRelations line 36 · specs/model/relation-reasons.sdp.md:36
no Gherkin form is invented for a relation reason, because relation tags carry no prose; a Spec that needs one is authored in Markdown or TypeScript.
intendedMentions line 37 · specs/model/relation-reasons.sdp.md:37
the mention audit (recipe 22) takes params.intended, rows { from, to, reason } keyed by Spec ids, and returns intended, the unbacked pairs a row matches with its reason, kept apart from the remaining pairs, and staleIntended, the rows that match no current pair.
Verification

Verifier bindings

  • test:protocol.authoring-grammar · checks rule keys, question fields and relation reasons across the carriers · anchored · test anchor binding present · test/authoring-grammar.test.ts:24

    External run evidence from test/authoring-grammar.test.ts

    Test anchors: test:protocol.authoring-grammar. Specs verified by those bindings: spec:model.open-question-fields, spec:model.relation-reasons, spec:model.rule-keys.

    Run 1: external run evidence from vitest 4.1.10

    Build: CI 391 · Branch: cursor/media-plan-and-articles-09b1 · Commit: 076cd4f1f85640d8236e5cca1bffffa68ab79a33 · Start: 2026-10-31T15:32:20.471Z · Stop: 2026-10-31T15:34:02.073Z

    NameSuiteResultDuration
    normalizes TypeScript keys and locates keyed and unkeyed rulesrule keyspassed23.57 ms
    normalizes Markdown keys and locates keyed and unkeyed rulesrule keyspassed5.85 ms
    normalizes Gherkin keys and locates keyed and unkeyed rulesrule keyspassed4.12 ms
    accepts keys on every Behavior entryrule keyspassed1.33 ms
    accepts keys on every Rule entryrule keyspassed0.98 ms
    accepts keys on every Workflow entryrule keyspassed1.1 ms
    accepts keys on every Contract entryrule keyspassed0.78 ms
    keeps the TypeScript field order when it keys flows and rulesrule keyspassed3.01 ms
    reports every repeated key in TypeScriptrule keyspassed3.45 ms
    reports every repeated key in Markdownrule keyspassed5.6 ms
    reports every repeated key in Gherkinrule keyspassed1.07 ms
    reports duplicate keys across rules and flows at both sitesrule keyspassed1.2 ms
    refuses malformed marker [#Bad] Text. in all carriersrule keyspassed4.17 ms
    refuses malformed marker [#bad-key] Text. in all carriersrule keyspassed4.03 ms
    refuses malformed marker [#] Text. in all carriersrule keyspassed3.23 ms
    refuses malformed marker [#key]Text. in all carriersrule keyspassed2.91 ms
    refuses malformed marker [#key] Text. in all carriersrule keyspassed3.62 ms
    refuses malformed marker [#key] in all carriersrule keyspassed3.14 ms
    omits ruleKeys when no rule is keyed and keeps Design Review rule text unchangedrule keyspassed2.97 ms
    carries an optional runtime reasonrelation attributespassed0.3 ms
    carries an optional runtime reasonrelation attributespassed0.23 ms
    carries an optional runtime reasonrelation attributespassed0.12 ms
    carries an optional runtime reasonrelation attributespassed0.1 ms
    carries an optional runtime reasonrelation attributespassed0.18 ms
    carries an optional runtime reasonrelation attributespassed0.13 ms
    carries exercises only from a declared verifies relationrelation attributespassed3.11 ms
    reads a target-only refines object as the plain idrelation attributespassed6.36 ms
    reads a target-only dependsOn object as the plain idrelation attributespassed10.14 ms
    reads a target-only constrainedBy object as the plain idrelation attributespassed4.88 ms
    reads a target-only decidedBy object as the plain idrelation attributespassed4.21 ms
    reads a target-only verifies object as the plain idrelation attributespassed10.63 ms
    reads a target-only supersedes object as the plain idrelation attributespassed5.02 ms
    accepts mixed Markdown target forms and TypeScript second argumentsrelation attributespassed3.11 ms
    refuses invalid relation options {reason: ""}relation attributespassed1.82 ms
    refuses invalid relation options {reason: "one\ntwo"}relation attributespassed1.93 ms
    refuses invalid relation options {strength: "hard"}relation attributespassed1.57 ms
    refuses invalid relation options {exercises: ["first"]}relation attributespassed1.48 ms
    refuses invalid Markdown relation options {reason: ""}relation attributespassed0.97 ms
    refuses invalid Markdown relation options {reason: "one\ntwo"}relation attributespassed0.6 ms
    refuses invalid Markdown relation options {aspect: "shape"}relation attributespassed0.5 ms
    refuses invalid Markdown relation options {exercises: [first]}relation attributespassed0.51 ms
    refuses invalid Markdown relation options {target: spec:probe.parent, reason: "x"}relation attributespassed0.94 ms
    refuses malformed exercises []relation attributespassed1.61 ms
    refuses malformed exercises ["first", "first"]relation attributespassed1.53 ms
    refuses malformed exercises ["Bad"]relation attributespassed1.33 ms
    refuses malformed exercises "first"relation attributespassed1.29 ms
    refuses a duplicate target across plain and object formsrelation attributespassed5.57 ms
    refuses a duplicate target shared by plain and target-only formsrelation attributespassed0.82 ms
    maps Gherkin exercises to the default or explicit verified targetrelation attributespassed3.47 ms
    refuses invalid Gherkin exercises @exercises.Badrelation attributespassed0.52 ms
    refuses invalid Gherkin exercises @exercises.first @exercises.firstrelation attributespassed0.29 ms
    refuses invalid Gherkin exercises @exercises.first @verifies.spec:probe.parent @verifies.spec:probe.otherrelation attributespassed0.31 ms
    refuses Gherkin exercises on a Feature or example spacerelation attributespassed1.24 ms
    refuses Gherkin exercises on an otherwise lawful example-space scenariogrammar boundary checkspassed0.5 ms
    refuses a malformed or near-miss exercises tag @exercisesgrammar boundary checkspassed0.52 ms
    refuses a malformed or near-miss exercises tag @exercise.firstgrammar boundary checkspassed0.4 ms
    keeps the carrier finding caps after common normalizationgrammar boundary checkspassed3.37 ms
    keeps collection order for rule keys when only some entries carry a linegrammar boundary checkspassed0.19 ms
    keeps relation finding lines after serialization reorders edgesgrammar boundary checkspassed1.41 ms
    refuses exercises on an anchored verifies edgegrammar boundary checkspassed0.65 ms
    refuses an unknown relation property even when its name is inheritedgrammar boundary checkspassed0.39 ms
    carries the fields through Markdown, serialization and the reader with exact linesquestion fieldspassed1.96 ms
    records TypeScript fields at their properties and leaves absent fields absentquestion fieldspassed2.38 ms
    refuses invalid Markdown field - decider: Owner at its linequestion fieldspassed0.49 ms
    refuses invalid Markdown field - decider: at its linequestion fieldspassed0.35 ms
    refuses invalid Markdown field - decider: owner - decider: delegated at its linequestion fieldspassed0.41 ms
    refuses invalid Markdown field - links: at its linequestion fieldspassed0.3 ms
    refuses invalid Markdown field - links: spec:probe.parent, spec:probe.parent at its linequestion fieldspassed0.28 ms
    refuses invalid Markdown field - provisional: at its linequestion fieldspassed0.33 ms
    refuses invalid Markdown field - trigger: at its linequestion fieldspassed0.29 ms
    refuses invalid Markdown field - status: waiting at its linequestion fieldspassed0.26 ms
    refuses invalid Markdown field - decider: owner at its linequestion fieldspassed0.45 ms
    refuses invalid Markdown field - decider: owner continuation at its linequestion fieldspassed0.43 ms
    refuses a trigger on a non-blocking question and a field outside a questionquestion fieldspassed1.59 ms
    refuses invalid TypeScript field decider: "Owner"question fieldspassed1.76 ms
    refuses invalid TypeScript field links: []question fieldspassed1.59 ms
    refuses invalid TypeScript field links: ["spec:probe.parent", "spec:probe.parent"]question fieldspassed3.89 ms
    refuses invalid TypeScript field provisional: "one\ntwo"question fieldspassed1.15 ms
    refuses invalid TypeScript field trigger: "A caller."question fieldspassed1.45 ms
    refuses invalid TypeScript field status: "waiting"question fieldspassed1.5 ms
    refuses invalid TypeScript field decider: "owner", decider: "delegated"question fieldspassed1.19 ms
    refuses invalid TypeScript field decider: selectOwner()question fieldspassed1.32 ms
    refuses invalid TypeScript field links: [ref("spec:probe.parent")]question fieldspassed1.24 ms
    refuses invalid TypeScript field links: ["spec:probe.parent", ...others]question fieldspassed1.13 ms
    checks every link as a complete token and groups unbacked pairs with prosequestion fieldspassed1.54 ms
    keeps readiness dependent on the blocking flag alonequestion fieldspassed1.41 ms
    preserves rule and flow keys, all question fields, reasons and exercisesTypeScript importpassed6.81 ms
  • test:protocol.authoring-grammar-recipes · executes the shipped question, mention, entry, address and rule coverage recipes · anchored · test anchor binding present · test/recipes.test.ts:6587

    External run evidence from test/recipes.test.ts

    Test anchors: test:protocol.address-and-cycle-recipes, test:protocol.answer-shape-recipes, test:protocol.authoring-grammar-recipes, test:protocol.authoring-recipes, test:protocol.capability-epics, test:protocol.capability-map, test:protocol.design-recipes, test:protocol.recipe-parameters, test:protocol.register-recipes. Specs verified by those bindings: spec:consumers.agent-surface.address-and-cycle-recipes, spec:consumers.agent-surface.answer-shapes, spec:consumers.agent-surface.authoring-recipes, spec:consumers.agent-surface.design-recipes, spec:consumers.agent-surface.recipe-parameters, spec:consumers.agent-surface.register-recipes, spec:consumers.capability-map, spec:extraction.contract-declarations, spec:model.open-question-fields, spec:model.relation-reasons, spec:model.rule-keys, spec:protocol.capability-epics.

    Run 1: external run evidence from vitest 4.1.10

    Build: CI 391 · Branch: cursor/media-plan-and-articles-09b1 · Commit: 076cd4f1f85640d8236e5cca1bffffa68ab79a33 · Start: 2026-10-31T15:32:20.471Z · Stop: 2026-10-31T15:34:02.073Z

    NameSuiteResultDuration
    cites each recipe that a Spec names by number and heading under the catalog's numberthe agent-surface recipe corpuspassed203.44 ms
    pairs every documented recipe with exactly one fenced bodythe agent-surface recipe corpuspassed1.09 ms
    keeps self-hosting and adopter invocation forms distinctthe agent-surface recipe corpuspassed7.14 ms
    teaches parameters as data and keeps the on-ramps naming the CLI verbs and recipesthe agent-surface recipe corpuspassed4.55 ms
    keeps every body plain JavaScript with a returnthe agent-surface recipe corpuspassed5.66 ms
    runs every body through the front door without throwingthe agent-surface recipe corpuspassed4526.76 ms
    returns the non-example build backlog and audits excluded example evidencethe agent-surface recipe corpuspassed71.36 ms
    returns a drift alarm of code-bound specs below ready, with the floor namedthe agent-surface recipe corpuspassed46.65 ms
    returns one spec's guarantees with its relations and verifier bindingsthe agent-surface recipe corpuspassed38.2 ms
    keeps hostile changed filenames as inert JSON datathe agent-surface recipe corpuspassed36.27 ms
    returns the complete diff-to-at-risk bridgethe agent-surface recipe corpuspassed48.16 ms
    names a changed identity-only unit as unlinked, never coverage-unknown or droppedthe agent-surface recipe corpuspassed66.24 ms
    returns a pack's review backbone with its verifier gapsthe agent-surface recipe corpuspassed54.38 ms
    returns concept matches carrying the fields that matchedthe agent-surface recipe corpuspassed86.65 ms
    returns readiness divergence as an array, where empty is lawfulthe agent-surface recipe corpuspassed94.47 ms
    returns the warn-level signals as data rather than as a gatethe agent-surface recipe corpuspassed57.35 ms
    returns promotion preflight without conferring a readiness editthe agent-surface recipe corpuspassed29.14 ms
    names the next rung's unmet clause and the dependency that breaks it on a probethe agent-surface recipe corpuspassed1.95 ms
    keeps declared examples distinct from enabled verifier bindingsthe agent-surface recipe corpuspassed315.12 ms
    returns the complete non-ready ladder grouped by familythe agent-surface recipe corpuspassed112.21 ms
    distinguishes a passing current floor from a blocked or clear stated next rungthe agent-surface recipe corpuspassed4.94 ms
    returns every committed structural component with non-empty membershipthe agent-surface recipe corpuspassed59.76 ms
    returns exact component uses fan-in and fan-out from the structural oraclethe agent-surface recipe corpuspassed47.86 ms
    returns a component structural neighborhood and an exact absent shapethe agent-surface recipe corpuspassed87.05 ms
    reports census structural coverage from graph and report ground truththe agent-surface recipe corpuspassed40.04 ms
    reports graph-side upper bounds for every shipped projection rootthe agent-surface recipe corpuspassed34.89 ms
    returns the architecture map of every live component with recomputed fan-in and fan-outthe agent-surface recipe corpuspassed54.87 ms
    explains the shared policy and adapter collaborations from graph intent and binding claimsthe agent-surface recipe corpuspassed69.84 ms
    retains local uses and their claims without counting a component as its own dependencythe agent-surface recipe corpuspassed75.74 ms
    preserves an unresolved responsibility without inventing its designthe agent-surface recipe corpuspassed89.93 ms
    keeps a dangling component row and surfaces unresolved uses edgesthe agent-surface recipe corpuspassed92.01 ms
    preserves an unresolved architecture-map member when memberOf outlives the nodethe agent-surface recipe corpuspassed86.53 ms
    returns the decision map ranked by live shaping fan-inthe agent-surface recipe corpuspassed49.06 ms
    returns a planning-slice neighborhood and an exact absent shapethe agent-surface recipe corpuspassed100.85 ms
    returns non-empty bidirectional dependencies for the binding-grain planning slicethe agent-surface recipe corpuspassed55.05 ms
    returns planning-slice implementations, never abstractionsthe agent-surface recipe corpuspassed49.58 ms
    preserves an unresolved component row when memberOf outlives the nodethe agent-surface recipe corpuspassed114.57 ms
    reports derived design columns beside the existing backlog fieldsthe agent-surface recipe corpuspassed5.97 ms
    groups backlog rows under lawful Object.prototype path segmentsthe agent-surface recipe corpuspassed70.12 ms
    groups lower-ladder rows under lawful Object.prototype path segmentsthe agent-surface recipe corpuspassed65.98 ms
    groups decided subjects under lawful Object.prototype path segmentsthe agent-surface recipe corpuspassed50.79 ms
    lists key families across the corpus in key, Spec and section order with the documented sampleregister recipe semanticspassed87.47 ms
    lists Design and UI key families without a row cap, preserving values, lines and overlapping prefixesregister recipe semanticspassed6.93 ms
    diagnoses an unresolved Pack member without returning a partial registerregister recipe semanticspassed2 ms
    diagnoses malformed key-family parameters without a register: {"prefixes":[]}register recipe semanticspassed47.39 ms
    diagnoses malformed key-family parameters without a register: {"prefixes":[""]}register recipe semanticspassed51.9 ms
    diagnoses malformed key-family parameters without a register: {"prefixes":["a","a"]}register recipe semanticspassed60.77 ms
    diagnoses malformed key-family parameters without a register: {"prefixes":"limit"}register recipe semanticspassed48.71 ms
    diagnoses malformed key-family parameters without a register: {"pack":"pack:absent"}register recipe semanticspassed47.17 ms
    diagnoses malformed key-family parameters without a register: {"specs":["spec:absent"]}register recipe semanticspassed47.63 ms
    diagnoses malformed key-family parameters without a register: {"specs":"bad"}register recipe semanticspassed48.35 ms
    diagnoses malformed key-family parameters without a register: {"pack":"pack:self-hosting-v1","specs":[]}register recipe semanticspassed61.9 ms
    runs recipe 20 as written in default outputregister recipe semanticspassed83.5 ms
    runs recipe 21 as written in default outputregister recipe semanticspassed43.91 ms
    runs recipe 22 as written in default outputregister recipe semanticspassed140.26 ms
    runs recipe 23 as written in default outputregister recipe semanticspassed135.22 ms
    runs recipe 24 as written in default outputregister recipe semanticspassed76.44 ms
    runs recipe 25 as written in default outputregister recipe semanticspassed32.84 ms
    runs recipe 26 as written in default outputregister recipe semanticspassed34.44 ms
    runs recipe 27 as written in default outputregister recipe semanticspassed35.78 ms
    runs recipe 28 as written in default outputregister recipe semanticspassed28.08 ms
    runs recipe 29 as written in default outputregister recipe semanticspassed25.29 ms
    runs recipe 30 as written in default outputregister recipe semanticspassed66.24 ms
    runs recipe 31 as written in default outputregister recipe semanticspassed36.6 ms
    runs recipe 32 as written in default outputregister recipe semanticspassed22.72 ms
    renders long JSON values with the same default text bound as stringsregister recipe semanticspassed7.07 ms
    registers an omitted blocking flag through a TypeScript carrierregister recipe semanticspassed2.89 ms
    searches coined keys of every value shape through a TypeScript carrierregister recipe semanticspassed2.3 ms
    searches strings inside a matching coined list or object keyregister recipe semanticspassed2.92 ms
    searches a null coined-key value in the reader graphregister recipe semanticspassed2.36 ms
    keeps register counts under totals and top-level plural nouns as arraysregister recipe semanticspassed602.26 ms
    pins whole-token matching for 'retry' in 'entry' / 'retry'register recipe semanticspassed1 ms
    pins whole-token matching for 'retry' in 'entry' / 'retryable'register recipe semanticspassed0.29 ms
    pins whole-token matching for 'retry' in 'entry' / 'retry-worker'register recipe semanticspassed0.22 ms
    pins whole-token matching for 'retry' in 'retryWorker' / 'unrelated'register recipe semanticspassed0.21 ms
    pins whole-token matching for 'Retry' in 'entry' / 'RETRY.'register recipe semanticspassed0.19 ms
    pins whole-token matching for 'retry worker' in 'retryWorker' / 'retry-worker'register recipe semanticspassed0.18 ms
    pins whole-token matching for 'retry worker' in 'entry' / 'worker retry'register recipe semanticspassed0.27 ms
    pins whole-token matching for 'retry worker' in 'entry' / 'retry the worker'register recipe semanticspassed0.18 ms
    pins whole-token matching for 'server' in 'entry' / 'HTTPServer'register recipe semanticspassed0.27 ms
    pins whole-token matching for 'v' in 'entry' / 'v2'register recipe semanticspassed0.21 ms
    registers every authored question, blocking Specs firstregister recipe semanticspassed65.36 ms
    reports one-hop footing of all four types, including unresolved targetsregister recipe semanticspassed94.97 ms
    audits mention pairs, skips fences, and preserves full ids and directionregister recipe semanticspassed1.17 ms
    resolves entry mentions and retains every token and pair location through a probe rootregister recipe semanticspassed5.54 ms
    reads the whole mention token through an underscore as malformed, never the existing prefixregister recipe semanticspassed0.73 ms
    reads the whole mention token through a slash as malformed, never the existing prefixregister recipe semanticspassed0.46 ms
    reads the whole mention token through a comma as malformed, never the existing prefixregister recipe semanticspassed0.49 ms
    reads the whole mention token through an underscore and a letter as malformed, never the existing prefixregister recipe semanticspassed0.42 ms
    reads the whole mention token through a slash and a letter as malformed, never the existing prefixregister recipe semanticspassed0.38 ms
    reads the whole mention token through a comma and a letter as malformed, never the existing prefixregister recipe semanticspassed0.4 ms
    reads the whole mention token through a letter outside ASCII as malformed, never the existing prefixregister recipe semanticspassed0.37 ms
    reads the whole mention token through an escaped underscore as malformed, never the existing prefixregister recipe semanticspassed0.36 ms
    reads the whole mention token through a combining mark as malformed, never the existing prefixregister recipe semanticspassed0.48 ms
    reads the whole mention token through a combining mark after an entry key as malformed, never the existing prefixregister recipe semanticspassed0.45 ms
    reads the whole mention token through a zero-width space as malformed, never the existing prefixregister recipe semanticspassed0.44 ms
    reads the whole mention token through fullwidth connector punctuation as malformed, never the existing prefixregister recipe semanticspassed0.4 ms
    reads the whole mention token through a NUL as malformed, never the existing prefixregister recipe semanticspassed0.41 ms
    reads the whole mention token through an escape character as malformed, never the existing prefixregister recipe semanticspassed0.39 ms
    reads the whole mention token through a delete character as malformed, never the existing prefixregister recipe semanticspassed0.55 ms
    reads the whole mention token through a C1 control character as malformed, never the existing prefixregister recipe semanticspassed0.43 ms
    reads the whole mention token through a hyphenated entry key as malformed, never the existing prefixregister recipe semanticspassed0.43 ms
    reads the whole mention token through an entry suffix with no key as malformed, never the existing prefixregister recipe semanticspassed0.43 ms
    reads the whole mention token through an entry suffix outside design and ui as malformed, never the existing prefixregister recipe semanticspassed0.44 ms
    reads the clean id through Markdown punctuation: a sentence dotregister recipe semanticspassed0.51 ms
    reads the clean id through Markdown punctuation: a commaregister recipe semanticspassed0.42 ms
    reads the clean id through Markdown punctuation: a colonregister recipe semanticspassed0.43 ms
    reads the clean id through Markdown punctuation: a closing parenthesisregister recipe semanticspassed0.41 ms
    reads the clean id through Markdown punctuation: boldregister recipe semanticspassed0.41 ms
    reads the clean id through Markdown punctuation: emphasisregister recipe semanticspassed0.41 ms
    reads the clean id through Markdown punctuation: strikethroughregister recipe semanticspassed0.38 ms
    reads the clean id through Markdown punctuation: backticksregister recipe semanticspassed0.43 ms
    reads the clean id through Markdown punctuation: ASCII double quotesregister recipe semanticspassed0.38 ms
    reads the clean id through Markdown punctuation: ASCII single quotesregister recipe semanticspassed0.53 ms
    reads the clean id through Markdown punctuation: typographic double quotesregister recipe semanticspassed0.46 ms
    reads the clean id through Markdown punctuation: typographic single quotesregister recipe semanticspassed0.43 ms
    reads the clean id through Markdown punctuation: an em dashregister recipe semanticspassed0.41 ms
    reads the clean id through Markdown punctuation: an en dashregister recipe semanticspassed0.43 ms
    reads the clean id through Markdown punctuation: an ellipsisregister recipe semanticspassed0.42 ms
    reads the clean id through Markdown punctuation: an escaped starregister recipe semanticspassed0.42 ms
    reads the clean id through Markdown punctuation: an escaped exclamation markregister recipe semanticspassed0.45 ms
    reads the clean id through Markdown punctuation: U+0085register recipe semanticspassed0.4 ms
    reads the clean id through Markdown punctuation: a no-break spaceregister recipe semanticspassed0.4 ms
    reads the clean id through Markdown punctuation: a tabregister recipe semanticspassed0.38 ms
    reads the clean id through Markdown punctuation: an arrowregister recipe semanticspassed0.37 ms
    reads a placeholder or a bare prefix as prose, not a mentionregister recipe semanticspassed0.47 ms
    scans nested arrays in examples while skipping object fences by positionregister recipe semanticspassed1.04 ms
    addresses only lawful Design and UI entry keys in search resultsregister recipe semanticspassed1.08 ms
    scopes mentions by the mentioning Spec onlyregister recipe semanticspassed3.1 ms
    reports malformed open questions without counting them: "one question"register recipe semanticspassed0.51 ms
    reports malformed open questions without counting them: {}register recipe semanticspassed0.28 ms
    reports malformed open questions without counting them: 42register recipe semanticspassed0.29 ms
    reports malformed open questions without counting them: {"blocking":true}register recipe semanticspassed0.27 ms
    reports malformed open questions without counting them: nullregister recipe semanticspassed0.32 ms
    reports malformed open questions without counting them: ""register recipe semanticspassed0.3 ms
    reports malformed open questions without counting them: {"question":"valid","blocking":"yes"}register recipe semanticspassed0.31 ms
    reports malformed open questions without counting them: {"question":"valid","blocking":null}register recipe semanticspassed0.33 ms
    reports malformed open questions without counting them: {"question":"valid"}register recipe semanticspassed0.38 ms
    reports an off-grammar question key as malformed: {"question":"valid","key":"AggregateReach"}register recipe semanticspassed0.46 ms
    reports an off-grammar question key as malformed: {"question":"valid","key":"aggregate-reach"}register recipe semanticspassed0.32 ms
    reports an off-grammar question key as malformed: {"question":"valid","key":""}register recipe semanticspassed0.33 ms
    reports an off-grammar question key as malformed: {"question":"valid","key":7}register recipe semanticspassed0.33 ms
    reports an off-grammar question key as malformed: {"question":"valid","key":null}register recipe semanticspassed0.31 ms
    reports an off-grammar question key as malformed: {"question":"valid","blocking":true}register recipe semanticspassed0.32 ms
    searches whole tokens, coined keys, narrative and fence stepsregister recipe semanticspassed10.86 ms
    lists every pinned declaration this corpus holdsregister recipe semanticspassed151.14 ms
    reads spans of any run length and skips every entry that pins nothingregister recipe semanticspassed0.81 ms
    resolves the catalog's addresses on this corpus as writtenaddress resolution and dependency cyclespassed64.16 ms
    reports this corpus's dependency cycles as an independent reachability check finds themaddress resolution and dependency cyclespassed88.32 ms
    reports the probe's one set and one self-dependent Spec, and nothing for a Spec that only reaches a setaddress resolution and dependency cyclespassed4.2 ms
    reports a self-loop inside a larger set only with that setaddress resolution and dependency cyclespassed4.72 ms
    walks targets in code-unit order, so of two tied shortest cycles the first target's is reportedaddress resolution and dependency cyclespassed6.46 ms
    walks a chain of 10,000 Specs and one cycle of 5,000 without recursingaddress resolution and dependency cyclespassed178.94 ms
    resolves an inherited property name only where the Spec authors it as a keyaddress resolution and dependency cyclespassed3.03 ms
    resolves the design's probe addresses with one row and one reason eachaddress resolution and dependency cyclespassed2.86 ms
    resolves a keyed question, refuses description in Design and UI, and keeps repeatsaddress resolution and dependency cyclespassed2.69 ms
    registers a keyed question with its key and an unkeyed one with a null keyaddress resolution and dependency cyclespassed1.76 ms
    audits a question address against the target's open question keysaddress resolution and dependency cyclespassed1.86 ms
    addresses a keyed question's text and matches its key, never the key as a rowaddress resolution and dependency cyclespassed5.05 ms
    returns one row per Studio member with four independent factsdesign references and the architecture taxonomypassed114.98 ms
    lists a referencing unit beside the realizing units without conferring implementeddesign references and the architecture taxonomypassed152.22 ms
    lists the reader beside each Studio member that depends on it, with its realizing unitsdesign references and the architecture taxonomypassed66.69 ms
    derives builds-on from the member's relations without conferring a fact on itdesign references and the architecture taxonomypassed154.09 ms
    returns the role, layer, and context taxonomy from the code units alonedesign references and the architecture taxonomypassed33.37 ms
    counts references as edges apart from the units that carry themdesign references and the architecture taxonomypassed83.72 ms
    creates each taxonomy bucket once, however many units share the valuedesign references and the architecture taxonomypassed102.31 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 1recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.86 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 2recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.45 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 3recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.48 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 4recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.4 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 5recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.39 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 6recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.39 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 7recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.42 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 8recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.45 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 9recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.44 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 10recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.41 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 11recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.36 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 12recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.35 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 13recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.98 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 14recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.42 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 15recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.38 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 16recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.38 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 17recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.34 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 18recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.36 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 19recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed3.5 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 20recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.42 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 21recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.42 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 22recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.4 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 23recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.38 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 24recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed3.6 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 25recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.41 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 26recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.41 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 27recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.44 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 28recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed3.48 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 29recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.4 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 30recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.39 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 31recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.36 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 32recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed3.39 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 33recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.45 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 34recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.36 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 35recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.39 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 36recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.45 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 37recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.41 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 38recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.37 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 39recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.38 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 40recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.39 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 41recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.38 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 42recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.39 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 43recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.43 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 44recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.4 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 45recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.39 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 46recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.37 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 47recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.38 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 48recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.42 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 49recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.41 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 50recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.42 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 51recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.37 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 52recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.47 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 53recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.48 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 54recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.56 ms
    declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 55recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.44 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 1recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed64.45 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 2recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed86.74 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 3recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed64.56 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 4recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed40.29 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 5recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed46.83 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 6recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed46.25 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 7recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed48.18 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 8recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed42.23 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 9recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed71.25 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 10recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed31.24 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 11recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed31.96 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 12recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed49.78 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 13recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed39.97 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 14recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed63.85 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 15recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed52.92 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 16recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed35.88 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 17recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed33.16 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 18recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed39.7 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 19recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed36.47 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 20recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed34.05 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 21recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed37.69 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 22recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed34.48 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 23recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed45.55 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 24recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed37.07 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 25recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed41.58 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 26recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed36.43 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 27recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed40.71 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 28recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed40.12 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 29recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed34.37 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 30recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed41.06 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 31recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed35.56 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 32recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed43.01 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 33recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed37.21 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 34recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed41.37 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 35recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed39.18 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 36recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed38.62 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 37recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed43.69 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 38recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed38.21 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 39recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed37.8 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 40recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed34.85 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 41recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed38.46 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 42recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed37.37 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 43recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed31.83 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 44recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed25.05 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 45recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed35.12 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 46recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed41.83 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 47recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed35.78 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 48recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed40.67 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 49recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed40.51 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 50recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed37.07 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 51recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed40.67 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 52recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed39.56 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 53recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed27.59 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 54recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed33.04 ms
    returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 55recipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed41.41 ms
    diagnoses wrong subject names, mixed known names and ordered unknown names through shipped bodiesrecipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed100 ms
    reads and names each parameter, with a fallback only when the contract supplies onerecipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed9.19 ms
    ships every catalog body as dist/recipes/NN-slug.js, byte for byterecipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed8.28 ms
    runs every shipped file, read whole, to the answer its catalog body givesrecipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed6827.51 ms
    refuses a catalog whose bodies and headings do not pair, rather than guess a file namerecipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed1.37 ms
    reads a CRLF catalog as its LF bodies, and refuses a catalog with no recipe before publishingrecipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed17.95 ms
    removes only completed recipe files the catalog no longer owes, never another run's temporary filerecipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed0.82 ms
    passes recipe 4 its changed files from a file named with @PATHrecipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed40.39 ms
    resolves the addresses recipe 25 receives as datarecipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed67.17 ms
    reads the Pack the Pack recipes review from params.packrecipe parameters and the shipped recipe filespassed187.66 ms
    returns the Pack design of every corpus Pack as the raw graph states itdesign recipespassed789.57 ms
    returns the probe Pack's design exactly, member by memberdesign recipespassed8.24 ms
    reaches every Spec resting on the corpus sample, by a shortest path of real edgesdesign recipespassed364.56 ms
    walks a dependency chain inbound only, once per Spec, and keeps a reference apartdesign recipespassed1.71 ms
    registers every corpus decision with its supersession, subjects and keyed questionsdesign recipespassed86.75 ms
    registers a supersedes pair both ways and a decision that shapes nothingdesign recipespassed4.58 ms
    carries a relation's reason beside the relation in recipes 3, 19, 21 and 31design recipespassed1.68 ms
    registers narrowing decisions both ways and excludes refinement by other kindsdesign recipespassed0.54 ms
    keeps the decoder in reader without adding crossings against the lawful notation alternativedesign recipespassed90.25 ms
    reports the corpus's architecture crossings as the raw edges state themdesign recipespassed61.19 ms
    names a crossing of two contexts and of two layers, and skips what cannot crossdesign recipespassed4.2 ms
    resolves every keyed corpus entry to its value and the line the location table recordsentry lines in entry search and address resolutionpassed134.85 ms
    gives each corpus entry-search row the line of a located entry and null otherwiseentry lines in entry search and address resolutionpassed220.2 ms
    never gives a nested entry the line of a literal top-level key its path spellsentry lines in entry search and address resolutionpassed4.76 ms
    counts a verifying Spec of another kind as a verifier, never as an example, in the Pack designentry lines in entry search and address resolutionpassed2.88 ms
    gives a string-form open question the line its question[n] row records, as the object formentry lines in entry search and address resolutionpassed5.46 ms
    counts equal layers and contexts between distinct components even without crossingsanswers that fitpassed0.51 ms
    returns guarantee entries and complete unit and verifier locations from contextanswers that fitpassed6.21 ms
    reports directions relative to an impacted Packanswers that fitpassed0.89 ms
    indexes exactly the present recipes with names, parameters and usesanswers that fitpassed3.39 ms
    runs a shipped body wrapped inside a caller's filteranswers that fitpassed112.01 ms
    keeps impact totals and puts both edge directions in the summaryanswers that fitpassed2.35 ms
    keeps the reader's Pack value in summary, full and selected-member answersanswers that fitpassed7.28 ms
    reports both next rungs when the stated rung is below the flooranswers that fitpassed0.62 ms
    reports no next rung at readyanswers that fitpassed35.24 ms
    reports gap exemptions and every omitted warning beyond the first 25answers that fitpassed2.84 ms
    lists only defined unimplemented designs and keeps exclusions and referencesanswers that fitpassed1.08 ms
    registers fields and counts deferrals apart from design holdsauthoring grammar recipespassed4.32 ms
    lists intended mentions apart and preserves the validator's warningsauthoring grammar recipespassed8.87 ms
    matches rule keys beside their text without searching the derived mapauthoring grammar recipespassed5.29 ms
    locates unkeyed rule text and question field textauthoring grammar recipespassed7.51 ms
    resolves rule addresses and preserves every parsed part of a missauthoring grammar recipespassed3 ms
    counts rule coverage from bound examples and reports unbound intent beside itauthoring grammar recipespassed3.01 ms
    reports missing rule-coverage scopes and accepts a scope with no rulesauthoring grammar recipespassed2.53 ms
    runs the catalog body in the evaluator without a module loaderentry citations recipepassed0.77 ms
    orders a declaration's citing files and lines independently of input orderentry citations recipepassed0.6 ms
    joins declarations and other cited entries, including uncited declarationsentry citations recipepassed0.74 ms
    includes absent Specs and malformed tokens only in the corpus unresolved listentry citations recipepassed1.17 ms
    returns diagnostics without findings for {"pack":"pack:missing"}entry citations recipepassed0.78 ms
    returns diagnostics without findings for {"specs":["spec:missing"]}entry citations recipepassed0.44 ms
    returns diagnostics without findings for {"specs":"spec:probe.cited"}entry citations recipepassed0.38 ms
    returns diagnostics without findings for {"pack":"pack:probe.citations","specs":[]}entry citations recipepassed0.41 ms
    returns diagnostics without findings for {"severity":"fatal"}entry citations recipepassed0.34 ms
    returns diagnostics without findings for {"severity":null}entry citations recipepassed0.44 ms
    reads an absent table as empty, and accepts an empty Spec scopeentry citations recipepassed0.48 ms
    adds recorded component fields, references, member roles and exact crossing-use countsStudio architecture and example-space recipe additionspassed82.69 ms
    runs shipped recipe 44 over every decoded space and refuses bad scopesStudio architecture and example-space recipe additionspassed425.18 ms
    runs recipe 45 as shipped and reports missing and malformed CTRF metadatanot recordedpassed462.11 ms
    recipe 49 renders the panel memo from its catalog body and refuses a malformed documentnot recordedpassed116.15 ms
    reports text-preserving rule and flow key changes apart from rewordingnot recordedpassed8.96 ms
    preserves a removed keyed rule address beside new unkeyed textnot recordedpassed2.6 ms
    preserves a removed keyed flow address beside new unkeyed textnot recordedpassed2.19 ms
    distinguishes removed unkeyed rule base positions from head positionsnot recordedpassed3.04 ms
    distinguishes removed unkeyed flow base positions from head positionsnot recordedpassed2.55 ms
    retains every diamond edge and intermediate node while counting each descendant oncethe capability map recipepassed1.25 ms
    returns summary/full parity with explicit omissions for scope {}the capability map recipepassed1.76 ms
    returns summary/full parity with explicit omissions for scope {"epic":"spec:probe.epic"}the capability map recipepassed1.06 ms
    normalizes prose and unflagged questions while preserving authored indicesthe capability map recipepassed0.38 ms
    retains null titles in serialized node and epic rows when a title degradesthe capability map recipepassed0.71 ms
    reports a self-refining epic as a cycle without making it its own parent epicthe capability map recipepassed2.75 ms
    uses the outside unreached parent as root rather than its child cycle groupthe capability map recipepassed0.49 ms
    selects an epic of kind behavior without changing its kindthe capability map recipepassed0.45 ms
    selects an epic of kind workflow without changing its kindthe capability map recipepassed0.25 ms
    selects an epic of kind example without changing its kindthe capability map recipepassed0.19 ms
    selects an epic of kind rule without changing its kindthe capability map recipepassed0.18 ms
    selects an epic of kind constraint without changing its kindthe capability map recipepassed0.19 ms
    selects an epic of kind model without changing its kindthe capability map recipepassed0.23 ms
    selects an epic of kind decision without changing its kindthe capability map recipepassed0.23 ms
    selects an epic of kind contract without changing its kindthe capability map recipepassed0.22 ms
    reads node evidence and ordered questions directly, including examples and decisions as parentsthe capability map recipepassed0.77 ms
    represents a missing floor as none and keeps the epic's evidence outside its rollupthe capability map recipepassed0.49 ms
    counts stated rungs separately from reached floors without lending a bound example's facts to its epicthe capability map recipepassed0.78 ms
    keeps nested and overlapping memberships and outside parents when selecting one epicthe capability map recipepassed1.12 ms
    traverses only declared refinement and never infers ancestry from other graph structurethe capability map recipepassed0.63 ms
    reports cycles, self-links and unresolved or non-Spec endpoints separately from parameter failuresthe capability map recipepassed0.54 ms
    limits damage to edges touching a selected epic scope and terminates reached cyclesthe capability map recipepassed0.34 ms
    keeps overlapping unreached root scopes unique and exposes an empty corpusthe capability map recipepassed0.34 ms
    refuses invalid parameters without a map: { epic: null }the capability map recipepassed0.17 ms
    refuses invalid parameters without a map: { epic: 1 }the capability map recipepassed0.11 ms
    refuses invalid parameters without a map: { epic: [] }the capability map recipepassed0.07 ms
    refuses invalid parameters without a map: { epic: 'spec:probe.absent' }the capability map recipepassed0.06 ms
    refuses invalid parameters without a map: { epic: 'spec:probe.plain' }the capability map recipepassed0.05 ms
    refuses invalid parameters without a map: { epic: 'impl:probe.non-spec' }the capability map recipepassed0.05 ms
    refuses invalid parameters without a map: { detail: 'true' }the capability map recipepassed0.05 ms
    refuses invalid parameters without a map: { detail: 1 }the capability map recipepassed0.05 ms
    refuses invalid parameters without a map: { detail: null }the capability map recipepassed0.05 ms
    refuses invalid parameters without a map: { epic: 1, detail: 'x' }the capability map recipepassed0.11 ms
    checks unknown names before known valuesthe capability map recipepassed0.11 ms
    answers deterministically in code-unit id order even when graph arrays are reversedthe capability map recipepassed1.22 ms
    reaches every Spec from the intended epic owners while preserving kinds and overlapping refinementthe Protocol's capability epicspassed207.42 ms
    keeps refinement and dependency from spec:extraction.build-pipeline to spec:extraction.derive-graphthe Protocol's capability epicspassed2.08 ms
    keeps refinement and dependency from spec:validation.corpus-rules to spec:consumers.agent-surfacethe Protocol's capability epicspassed2.24 ms
    keeps refinement and dependency from spec:validation.architecture-constraints to spec:validation.corpus-rulesthe Protocol's capability epicspassed2.19 ms
    keeps refinement and dependency from spec:validation.external-registers to spec:validation.corpus-rulesthe Protocol's capability epicspassed2.35 ms
    keeps every ready statement at the ready floor and leaves the drift alarm emptythe Protocol's capability epicspassed73.37 ms
    runs the catalog body over the arc Pack through the CLI and keeps its summary totalsthe shipped design slicepassed359.23 ms
    runs the roadmap and its memo from the catalog over a named Packnot recordedpassed283.82 ms
    pins the adopter roadmap and its forward memo over the worked examplenot recordedpassed24.1 ms
Design view

Requirement drawing

  • Declared verifying examples: no declared verifying example.
Requirement drawing for spec:model.relation-reasons
The diagram as text
  • spec:model.relation-reasons: An authored relation may carry its reason · declared Spec
  • spec:model.relations: Specs declare typed directed relations · declared Spec
  • impl:protocol.authoring-grammar-recipes: asserts the authoring grammar's realization in docs/agent-surface/recipes.md · anchored code · test/recipes.test.ts:6597
  • impl:protocol.authoring-normalization: normalizes rule markers and question fields after carrier reification · anchored code · src/extract/authoring-normalization.ts:8
  • test:protocol.authoring-grammar: checks rule keys, question fields and relation reasons across the carriers · anchored test binding · binding present · test/authoring-grammar.test.ts:24
  • test:protocol.authoring-grammar-recipes: executes the shipped question, mention, entry, address and rule coverage recipes · anchored test binding · binding present · test/recipes.test.ts:6587
  • spec:model.relation-reasons refines spec:model.relations · declared
  • impl:protocol.authoring-grammar-recipes satisfies spec:model.relation-reasons · anchored
  • impl:protocol.authoring-normalization satisfies spec:model.relation-reasons · anchored
  • test:protocol.authoring-grammar verifies spec:model.relation-reasons · anchored
  • test:protocol.authoring-grammar-recipes verifies spec:model.relation-reasons · anchored
Mermaid source

Copyable source; the Studio draws static SVG.

Preferred and chosen syntax: requirementDiagram; exact refines, satisfies and verifies, with claim words in nodes and per-edge comments.

Decisions

Runtime
  • component:protocol.extract · the carrier and source pipeline · src/extract/index.ts:192 · layer application · context protocol

    Uses

    • component:protocol.graph · the one graph and its semantic decisions · src/graph/schema.ts:34 · layer domain · context protocol
    • component:protocol.model · the authored contracts and stable ids · src/model/anchors.ts:100 · layer domain · context protocol
    • component:protocol.notation · the leaf step codec · src/notation/slots.ts:261 · layer domain · context protocol
    • component:protocol.validate · one finding currency and ordered checks · src/validate/validators.ts:72 · layer domain · context protocol
  • impl:protocol.authoring-grammar-recipes · asserts the authoring grammar's realization in docs/agent-surface/recipes.md · test/recipes.test.ts:6597

    Uses

    None.

  • impl:protocol.authoring-normalization · normalizes rule markers and question fields after carrier reification · src/extract/authoring-normalization.ts:8

    Component: component:protocol.extract · the carrier and source pipeline · src/extract/index.ts:192 · layer application · context protocol

    Uses

    None.

Runtime observation: not tracked.

Evidence

Runtime observation: not tracked.

Build attestations: not tracked.

Deployments: not tracked.

Bills of materials: not tracked.

Impact
Relations of spec:model.relation-reasons
The diagram as text
  • spec:carrier.envelope-contract: The Markdown envelope is explicit and bounded
  • spec:carrier.prose-ownership-rule: Every prose value has one typed owner
  • spec:consumers.agent-surface.register-recipes: Register questions stay executable graph recipes
  • spec:consumers.authoring-on-ramp: Authors move one Spec from intent to reviewed evidence
  • spec:consumers.spec-studio.spec-page: A Spec page shows one Spec in collapsible panels, in a fixed order
  • spec:consumers.spec-studio.spec-page.core: A Spec page's core shows the whole Spec, with an anchor for every entry
  • spec:consumers.upgrade-kit.capability-adoption: Capability adoption counts where each capability is used and where it could apply
  • spec:decisions.prose-ownership: Prose belongs to typed graph owners
  • spec:model.relation-reasons: An authored relation may carry its reason
  • spec:model.relations: Specs declare typed directed relations
  • spec:model.relation-reasons decidedBy spec:decisions.prose-ownership · declared — the relation owns its reason as typed prose
  • spec:model.relation-reasons refines spec:model.relations · declared
  • spec:carrier.envelope-contract dependsOn spec:model.relation-reasons · declared
  • spec:carrier.prose-ownership-rule dependsOn spec:model.relation-reasons · declared
  • spec:consumers.agent-surface.register-recipes dependsOn spec:model.relation-reasons · declared — the mention audit reads a caller's intended mentions with their reasons
  • spec:consumers.authoring-on-ramp dependsOn spec:model.relation-reasons · declared
  • spec:consumers.spec-studio.spec-page dependsOn spec:model.relation-reasons · declared
  • spec:consumers.spec-studio.spec-page.core dependsOn spec:model.relation-reasons · declared
  • spec:consumers.upgrade-kit.capability-adoption dependsOn spec:model.relation-reasons · declared — relation reasons are counted where authored relations are
Mermaid source

Copyable source; the Studio draws static SVG.

Preferred syntax: flowchart. Chosen syntax: labelled flowchart, preserving exact relations, claims and folds.

Rests on

Rested on by

Distance 1

Distance 2

Distance 3

Distance 4

Distance 5

Distance 6

Distance 7

Distance 8

Distance 9

Relations

Relation and directionOther endClaimReasonExercised keys
decidedBy · outgoingProse belongs to typed graph owners
spec:decisions.prose-ownership · resolves
declaredthe relation owns its reason as typed proseNone
refines · outgoingSpecs declare typed directed relations
spec:model.relations · resolves
declaredNoneNone
dependsOn · incomingThe Markdown envelope is explicit and bounded
spec:carrier.envelope-contract · resolves
declaredNoneNone
dependsOn · incomingEvery prose value has one typed owner
spec:carrier.prose-ownership-rule · resolves
declaredNoneNone
dependsOn · incomingRegister questions stay executable graph recipes
spec:consumers.agent-surface.register-recipes · resolves
declaredthe mention audit reads a caller's intended mentions with their reasonsNone
dependsOn · incomingAuthors move one Spec from intent to reviewed evidence
spec:consumers.authoring-on-ramp · resolves
declaredNoneNone
dependsOn · incomingA Spec page shows one Spec in collapsible panels, in a fixed order
spec:consumers.spec-studio.spec-page · resolves
declaredNoneNone
dependsOn · incomingA Spec page's core shows the whole Spec, with an anchor for every entry
spec:consumers.spec-studio.spec-page.core · resolves
declaredNoneNone
dependsOn · incomingCapability adoption counts where each capability is used and where it could apply
spec:consumers.upgrade-kit.capability-adoption · resolves
declaredrelation reasons are counted where authored relations areNone

Bindings

Implementation binding: present

  • impl:protocol.authoring-grammar-recipes · asserts the authoring grammar's realization in docs/agent-surface/recipes.md · test/recipes.test.ts:6597
  • impl:protocol.authoring-normalization · normalizes rule markers and question fields after carrier reification · src/extract/authoring-normalization.ts:8 · role codec · component component:protocol.extract · layer application · context protocol

Design reference: none

Verifier binding: present

  • test:protocol.authoring-grammar · checks rule keys, question fields and relation reasons across the carriers · anchored · test/authoring-grammar.test.ts:24 · test anchor
  • test:protocol.authoring-grammar-recipes · executes the shipped question, mention, entry, address and rule coverage recipes · anchored · test/recipes.test.ts:6587 · test anchor

Expected-outcome oracle: none

Runtime observation: not tracked.

Run results: not recorded in the graph.

Findings

None.

Composing (0)

Composing needs the script.