Recipe answers fit an agent's context and explain their misses

actor

An agent answering a delivery question through the catalog recipes.

problem

An agent spends calls trimming oversized answers, decoding terse misses and writing the same missing body, and can repeat a recipe's label as fact when the label says more than the graph does.

outcome

Let an agent get each answer in one call that fits its context, with every miss explained.

rule line 25 · specs/consumers/agent-surface.answer-shapes.sdp.md:25

Changed-file impact, Pack design, design diff and the design slice, recipes 4, 29, 35 and 54, accept detail: true and default to summaries preserving every total and explicitly naming omitted detail.

rule line 26 · specs/consumers/agent-surface.answer-shapes.sdp.md:26

The guarantees recipe (recipe 3) returns each section's entries as the Spec states them and the binding fields the Spec context carries, not only the names of the sections.

rule line 27 · specs/consumers/agent-surface.answer-shapes.sdp.md:27

The orphans and gaps recipe (recipe 8) reports each kind the verifier-gap signal exempts and how many ready Specs it exempts, as the build backlog reports its exclusions.

rule line 28 · specs/consumers/agent-surface.answer-shapes.sdp.md:28

A design-backlog recipe lists the Specs stated defined that no code realizes, with their design columns, excluding examples and decisions as the build backlog does.

rule line 29 · specs/consumers/agent-surface.answer-shapes.sdp.md:29

The catalog opens with an index, one row per recipe, and shows how to run a shipped body inside a caller's own body to filter its answer.

5 unkeyed rules.

detailParameter line 33 · specs/consumers/agent-surface.answer-shapes.sdp.md:33

recipes 4, 29, 35 and 54 read params.detail, absent or false for the summary and true for every row in full; recipe 29's and recipe 54's detail may also be a list of member ids, which returns full rows for those members and summary rows for the rest of the Pack, and an id that is not a member is a diagnostic in the result. A summary keeps totals as the full answer counts them and adds leftOut, one line for each kind of detail it omits.

impactSummary line 34 · specs/consumers/agent-surface.answer-shapes.sdp.md:34

{ changedFiles, totals, impactedSpecs: [id], impactedPacks: [id], atRisk: { incomingSpecs: [id], outgoingSpecs: [id], other: [id] }, coverageUnknownFiles, unlinkedUnits: [id], leftOut } is recipe 4's summary. Incoming and outgoing name the connecting edge's direction relative to the impacted node and assert no dependency, since the edge may be any type; a Spec reached both ways is listed in both, and other holds the at-risk nodes that are not Specs.

no citation recorded

impactDetail line 35 · specs/consumers/agent-surface.answer-shapes.sdp.md:35

With detail: true, recipe 4 returns full rows and reasons; every at-risk reason carries direction, incoming or outgoing, relative to its impacted end.

packDesignSummary line 36 · specs/consumers/agent-surface.answer-shapes.sdp.md:36

{ id, specKind, statedReadiness, floorReached, statedNextRung, holds: [{ clauseId, targets: [id] }], openQuestions, blockingQuestions, implementedBy, referencedBy } is recipe 29's summary row, with counts for the last four; the summary's boundary lists ids per direction, and totals is unchanged. holds is the summary of statedNextRungFailures, retaining each clauseId and target ids.

no citation recorded

guaranteeShape line 37 · specs/consumers/agent-surface.answer-shapes.sdp.md:37

Recipe 3 returns sections as the graph holds them, designColumns, packs, implementations and references in recipe 29's unit shape, with id, file, line, role and component with its layer and context, plus each verifier with its line, relations with claims and reasons, and findings.

gapExemptions line 38 · specs/consumers/agent-surface.answer-shapes.sdp.md:38

Recipe 8 returns exemptions as { validatorId, exemptKind, readySpecs }, one row for each exempt kind, and leftOut when more signals exist than the 25 listed.

preflightRungs line 39 · specs/consumers/agent-surface.answer-shapes.sdp.md:39

The Spec context carries statedNextRung when one exists and statedNextRungFailures; promotion preflight reads those fields and the floor's next rung without computing a floor, and renders a missing next rung as null.

designBacklog line 40 · specs/consumers/agent-surface.answer-shapes.sdp.md:40

recipe 33, the design backlog, takes no parameter and returns { totals: { specs, byFamily, excludedExamples, excludedDecisions, withReferences }, rows }, each row { id, specKind, altitude, floorReached, statedNextRungFailures: [clauseId], design: { entries, declarations, openQuestions, blockingQuestions }, referencedBy, packs }, sorted by id.

catalogIndex line 41 · specs/consumers/agent-surface.answer-shapes.sdp.md:41

the catalog opens with a table of every recipe, its number, name, parameters and a one-line use, before the contract; the build writes one file per body and none for the index.

wrapIdiom line 42 · specs/consumers/agent-surface.answer-shapes.sdp.md:42

to filter a shipped answer, the caller wraps the shipped body in an async arrow function that takes params, inside its own body, const answer = await (async (params) => { <shipped body> })({ <the recipe's own parameters> });, and returns a filtered value, so the caller's own parameters never reach the recipe as names it does not take; the catalog shows the shell form and states that the caller's part must hold no shell expansion.

Verifier bindings

• test:protocol.answer-shape-recipes · anchored · test anchor binding present · test/recipes.test.ts:6220

  External run evidence from test/recipes.test.ts

  Test anchors: test:protocol.address-and-cycle-recipes, test:protocol.answer-shape-recipes, test:protocol.authoring-grammar-recipes, test:protocol.authoring-recipes, test:protocol.capability-epics, test:protocol.capability-map, test:protocol.design-recipes, test:protocol.recipe-parameters, test:protocol.register-recipes. Specs verified by those bindings: spec:consumers.agent-surface.address-and-cycle-recipes, spec:consumers.agent-surface.answer-shapes, spec:consumers.agent-surface.authoring-recipes, spec:consumers.agent-surface.design-recipes, spec:consumers.agent-surface.recipe-parameters, spec:consumers.agent-surface.register-recipes, spec:consumers.capability-map, spec:extraction.contract-declarations, spec:model.open-question-fields, spec:model.relation-reasons, spec:model.rule-keys, spec:protocol.capability-epics.

  Run 1: external run evidence from vitest 4.1.10

  Build: CI 380 · Branch: feature/roadmap-and-slices-v0 · Commit: 34909918bf0be0e849959644401797191cae379f · Start: 2026-10-22T17:40:31.456Z · Stop: 2026-10-22T17:42:16.171Z

  Name	Suite	Result	Duration
  cites each recipe that a Spec names by number and heading under the catalog's number	the agent-surface recipe corpus	passed	213.54 ms
  pairs every documented recipe with exactly one fenced body	the agent-surface recipe corpus	passed	0.81 ms
  keeps self-hosting and adopter invocation forms distinct	the agent-surface recipe corpus	passed	4.35 ms
  teaches parameters as data and keeps the on-ramps naming the CLI verbs and recipes	the agent-surface recipe corpus	passed	3.84 ms
  keeps every body plain JavaScript with a return	the agent-surface recipe corpus	passed	5.18 ms
  runs every body through the front door without throwing	the agent-surface recipe corpus	passed	4864.59 ms
  returns the non-example build backlog and audits excluded example evidence	the agent-surface recipe corpus	passed	74.13 ms
  returns a drift alarm of code-bound specs below ready, with the floor named	the agent-surface recipe corpus	passed	63.42 ms
  returns one spec's guarantees with its relations and verifier bindings	the agent-surface recipe corpus	passed	26.84 ms
  keeps hostile changed filenames as inert JSON data	the agent-surface recipe corpus	passed	40.2 ms
  returns the complete diff-to-at-risk bridge	the agent-surface recipe corpus	passed	52.87 ms
  names a changed identity-only unit as unlinked, never coverage-unknown or dropped	the agent-surface recipe corpus	passed	74.55 ms
  returns a pack's review backbone with its verifier gaps	the agent-surface recipe corpus	passed	53.36 ms
  returns concept matches carrying the fields that matched	the agent-surface recipe corpus	passed	97.83 ms
  returns readiness divergence as an array, where empty is lawful	the agent-surface recipe corpus	passed	128.59 ms
  returns the warn-level signals as data rather than as a gate	the agent-surface recipe corpus	passed	73.52 ms
  returns promotion preflight without conferring a readiness edit	the agent-surface recipe corpus	passed	32.89 ms
  names the next rung's unmet clause and the dependency that breaks it on a probe	the agent-surface recipe corpus	passed	3.63 ms
  keeps declared examples distinct from enabled verifier bindings	the agent-surface recipe corpus	passed	243.11 ms
  returns the complete non-ready ladder grouped by family	the agent-surface recipe corpus	passed	85.21 ms
  distinguishes a passing current floor from a blocked or clear stated next rung	the agent-surface recipe corpus	passed	1.73 ms
  returns every committed structural component with non-empty membership	the agent-surface recipe corpus	passed	57.07 ms
  returns exact component uses fan-in and fan-out from the structural oracle	the agent-surface recipe corpus	passed	36.72 ms
  returns a component structural neighborhood and an exact absent shape	the agent-surface recipe corpus	passed	57.12 ms
  reports census structural coverage from graph and report ground truth	the agent-surface recipe corpus	passed	32.63 ms
  reports graph-side upper bounds for every shipped projection root	the agent-surface recipe corpus	passed	35.68 ms
  returns the architecture map of every live component with recomputed fan-in and fan-out	the agent-surface recipe corpus	passed	66.26 ms
  explains the shared policy and adapter collaborations from graph intent and binding claims	the agent-surface recipe corpus	passed	71.08 ms
  retains local uses and their claims without counting a component as its own dependency	the agent-surface recipe corpus	passed	108.03 ms
  preserves an unresolved responsibility without inventing its design	the agent-surface recipe corpus	passed	104.03 ms
  keeps a dangling component row and surfaces unresolved uses edges	the agent-surface recipe corpus	passed	94.74 ms
  preserves an unresolved architecture-map member when memberOf outlives the node	the agent-surface recipe corpus	passed	126.1 ms
  returns the decision map ranked by live shaping fan-in	the agent-surface recipe corpus	passed	66.23 ms
  returns a planning-slice neighborhood and an exact absent shape	the agent-surface recipe corpus	passed	109.75 ms
  returns non-empty bidirectional dependencies for the binding-grain planning slice	the agent-surface recipe corpus	passed	50.88 ms
  returns planning-slice implementations, never abstractions	the agent-surface recipe corpus	passed	48.26 ms
  preserves an unresolved component row when memberOf outlives the node	the agent-surface recipe corpus	passed	115.85 ms
  reports derived design columns beside the existing backlog fields	the agent-surface recipe corpus	passed	0.91 ms
  groups backlog rows under lawful Object.prototype path segments	the agent-surface recipe corpus	passed	65.08 ms
  groups lower-ladder rows under lawful Object.prototype path segments	the agent-surface recipe corpus	passed	50.37 ms
  groups decided subjects under lawful Object.prototype path segments	the agent-surface recipe corpus	passed	44.22 ms
  lists key families across the corpus in key, Spec and section order with the documented sample	register recipe semantics	passed	91.93 ms
  lists Design and UI key families without a row cap, preserving values, lines and overlapping prefixes	register recipe semantics	passed	9.14 ms
  diagnoses an unresolved Pack member without returning a partial register	register recipe semantics	passed	2.01 ms
  diagnoses malformed key-family parameters without a register: {"prefixes":[]}	register recipe semantics	passed	40.51 ms
  diagnoses malformed key-family parameters without a register: {"prefixes":[""]}	register recipe semantics	passed	39.18 ms
  diagnoses malformed key-family parameters without a register: {"prefixes":["a","a"]}	register recipe semantics	passed	57.21 ms
  diagnoses malformed key-family parameters without a register: {"prefixes":"limit"}	register recipe semantics	passed	44.46 ms
  diagnoses malformed key-family parameters without a register: {"pack":"pack:absent"}	register recipe semantics	passed	37.73 ms
  diagnoses malformed key-family parameters without a register: {"specs":["spec:absent"]}	register recipe semantics	passed	54.73 ms
  diagnoses malformed key-family parameters without a register: {"specs":"bad"}	register recipe semantics	passed	45.75 ms
  diagnoses malformed key-family parameters without a register: {"pack":"pack:self-hosting-v1","specs":[]}	register recipe semantics	passed	69.9 ms
  runs recipe 20 as written in default output	register recipe semantics	passed	102.17 ms
  runs recipe 21 as written in default output	register recipe semantics	passed	55.05 ms
  runs recipe 22 as written in default output	register recipe semantics	passed	91.83 ms
  runs recipe 23 as written in default output	register recipe semantics	passed	111.17 ms
  runs recipe 24 as written in default output	register recipe semantics	passed	78.19 ms
  runs recipe 25 as written in default output	register recipe semantics	passed	39.83 ms
  runs recipe 26 as written in default output	register recipe semantics	passed	35.69 ms
  runs recipe 27 as written in default output	register recipe semantics	passed	40.73 ms
  runs recipe 28 as written in default output	register recipe semantics	passed	28.53 ms
  runs recipe 29 as written in default output	register recipe semantics	passed	28.55 ms
  runs recipe 30 as written in default output	register recipe semantics	passed	113.58 ms
  runs recipe 31 as written in default output	register recipe semantics	passed	39.91 ms
  runs recipe 32 as written in default output	register recipe semantics	passed	27.27 ms
  renders long JSON values with the same default text bound as strings	register recipe semantics	passed	7.28 ms
  registers an omitted blocking flag through a TypeScript carrier	register recipe semantics	passed	3.03 ms
  searches coined keys of every value shape through a TypeScript carrier	register recipe semantics	passed	2.71 ms
  searches strings inside a matching coined list or object key	register recipe semantics	passed	2.2 ms
  searches a null coined-key value in the reader graph	register recipe semantics	passed	1.75 ms
  keeps register counts under totals and top-level plural nouns as arrays	register recipe semantics	passed	821.5 ms
  pins whole-token matching for 'retry' in 'entry' / 'retry'	register recipe semantics	passed	1.24 ms
  pins whole-token matching for 'retry' in 'entry' / 'retryable'	register recipe semantics	passed	0.4 ms
  pins whole-token matching for 'retry' in 'entry' / 'retry-worker'	register recipe semantics	passed	0.35 ms
  pins whole-token matching for 'retry' in 'retryWorker' / 'unrelated'	register recipe semantics	passed	0.32 ms
  pins whole-token matching for 'Retry' in 'entry' / 'RETRY.'	register recipe semantics	passed	0.32 ms
  pins whole-token matching for 'retry worker' in 'retryWorker' / 'retry-worker'	register recipe semantics	passed	0.33 ms
  pins whole-token matching for 'retry worker' in 'entry' / 'worker retry'	register recipe semantics	passed	0.36 ms
  pins whole-token matching for 'retry worker' in 'entry' / 'retry the worker'	register recipe semantics	passed	0.29 ms
  pins whole-token matching for 'server' in 'entry' / 'HTTPServer'	register recipe semantics	passed	0.43 ms
  pins whole-token matching for 'v' in 'entry' / 'v2'	register recipe semantics	passed	0.33 ms
  registers every authored question, blocking Specs first	register recipe semantics	passed	81.67 ms
  reports one-hop footing of all four types, including unresolved targets	register recipe semantics	passed	116.61 ms
  audits mention pairs, skips fences, and preserves full ids and direction	register recipe semantics	passed	1.37 ms
  resolves entry mentions and retains every token and pair location through a probe root	register recipe semantics	passed	8.35 ms
  reads the whole mention token through an underscore as malformed, never the existing prefix	register recipe semantics	passed	0.8 ms
  reads the whole mention token through a slash as malformed, never the existing prefix	register recipe semantics	passed	0.5 ms
  reads the whole mention token through a comma as malformed, never the existing prefix	register recipe semantics	passed	9.19 ms
  reads the whole mention token through an underscore and a letter as malformed, never the existing prefix	register recipe semantics	passed	0.75 ms
  reads the whole mention token through a slash and a letter as malformed, never the existing prefix	register recipe semantics	passed	0.49 ms
  reads the whole mention token through a comma and a letter as malformed, never the existing prefix	register recipe semantics	passed	0.48 ms
  reads the whole mention token through a letter outside ASCII as malformed, never the existing prefix	register recipe semantics	passed	0.48 ms
  reads the whole mention token through an escaped underscore as malformed, never the existing prefix	register recipe semantics	passed	3.54 ms
  reads the whole mention token through a combining mark as malformed, never the existing prefix	register recipe semantics	passed	0.6 ms
  reads the whole mention token through a combining mark after an entry key as malformed, never the existing prefix	register recipe semantics	passed	0.54 ms
  reads the whole mention token through a zero-width space as malformed, never the existing prefix	register recipe semantics	passed	0.45 ms
  reads the whole mention token through fullwidth connector punctuation as malformed, never the existing prefix	register recipe semantics	passed	0.45 ms
  reads the whole mention token through a NUL as malformed, never the existing prefix	register recipe semantics	passed	0.42 ms
  reads the whole mention token through an escape character as malformed, never the existing prefix	register recipe semantics	passed	3.48 ms
  reads the whole mention token through a delete character as malformed, never the existing prefix	register recipe semantics	passed	0.57 ms
  reads the whole mention token through a C1 control character as malformed, never the existing prefix	register recipe semantics	passed	0.47 ms
  reads the whole mention token through a hyphenated entry key as malformed, never the existing prefix	register recipe semantics	passed	0.44 ms
  reads the whole mention token through an entry suffix with no key as malformed, never the existing prefix	register recipe semantics	passed	0.47 ms
  reads the whole mention token through an entry suffix outside design and ui as malformed, never the existing prefix	register recipe semantics	passed	0.44 ms
  reads the clean id through Markdown punctuation: a sentence dot	register recipe semantics	passed	3.84 ms
  reads the clean id through Markdown punctuation: a comma	register recipe semantics	passed	0.64 ms
  reads the clean id through Markdown punctuation: a colon	register recipe semantics	passed	0.49 ms
  reads the clean id through Markdown punctuation: a closing parenthesis	register recipe semantics	passed	0.51 ms
  reads the clean id through Markdown punctuation: bold	register recipe semantics	passed	0.49 ms
  reads the clean id through Markdown punctuation: emphasis	register recipe semantics	passed	0.46 ms
  reads the clean id through Markdown punctuation: strikethrough	register recipe semantics	passed	0.43 ms
  reads the clean id through Markdown punctuation: backticks	register recipe semantics	passed	0.41 ms
  reads the clean id through Markdown punctuation: ASCII double quotes	register recipe semantics	passed	0.45 ms
  reads the clean id through Markdown punctuation: ASCII single quotes	register recipe semantics	passed	0.41 ms
  reads the clean id through Markdown punctuation: typographic double quotes	register recipe semantics	passed	0.83 ms
  reads the clean id through Markdown punctuation: typographic single quotes	register recipe semantics	passed	0.44 ms
  reads the clean id through Markdown punctuation: an em dash	register recipe semantics	passed	0.38 ms
  reads the clean id through Markdown punctuation: an en dash	register recipe semantics	passed	0.36 ms
  reads the clean id through Markdown punctuation: an ellipsis	register recipe semantics	passed	0.41 ms
  reads the clean id through Markdown punctuation: an escaped star	register recipe semantics	passed	0.45 ms
  reads the clean id through Markdown punctuation: an escaped exclamation mark	register recipe semantics	passed	0.47 ms
  reads the clean id through Markdown punctuation: U+0085	register recipe semantics	passed	0.42 ms
  reads the clean id through Markdown punctuation: a no-break space	register recipe semantics	passed	0.44 ms
  reads the clean id through Markdown punctuation: a tab	register recipe semantics	passed	0.45 ms
  reads the clean id through Markdown punctuation: an arrow	register recipe semantics	passed	0.48 ms
  reads a placeholder or a bare prefix as prose, not a mention	register recipe semantics	passed	0.45 ms
  scans nested arrays in examples while skipping object fences by position	register recipe semantics	passed	3.07 ms
  addresses only lawful Design and UI entry keys in search results	register recipe semantics	passed	1.09 ms
  scopes mentions by the mentioning Spec only	register recipe semantics	passed	3.21 ms
  reports malformed open questions without counting them: "one question"	register recipe semantics	passed	2.52 ms
  reports malformed open questions without counting them: {}	register recipe semantics	passed	0.29 ms
  reports malformed open questions without counting them: 42	register recipe semantics	passed	0.26 ms
  reports malformed open questions without counting them: {"blocking":true}	register recipe semantics	passed	0.26 ms
  reports malformed open questions without counting them: null	register recipe semantics	passed	0.21 ms
  reports malformed open questions without counting them: ""	register recipe semantics	passed	0.23 ms
  reports malformed open questions without counting them: {"question":"valid","blocking":"yes"}	register recipe semantics	passed	0.22 ms
  reports malformed open questions without counting them: {"question":"valid","blocking":null}	register recipe semantics	passed	0.28 ms
  reports malformed open questions without counting them: {"question":"valid"}	register recipe semantics	passed	0.34 ms
  reports an off-grammar question key as malformed: {"question":"valid","key":"AggregateReach"}	register recipe semantics	passed	0.5 ms
  reports an off-grammar question key as malformed: {"question":"valid","key":"aggregate-reach"}	register recipe semantics	passed	0.3 ms
  reports an off-grammar question key as malformed: {"question":"valid","key":""}	register recipe semantics	passed	0.29 ms
  reports an off-grammar question key as malformed: {"question":"valid","key":7}	register recipe semantics	passed	0.26 ms
  reports an off-grammar question key as malformed: {"question":"valid","key":null}	register recipe semantics	passed	0.29 ms
  reports an off-grammar question key as malformed: {"question":"valid","blocking":true}	register recipe semantics	passed	0.29 ms
  searches whole tokens, coined keys, narrative and fence steps	register recipe semantics	passed	9.63 ms
  lists every pinned declaration this corpus holds	register recipe semantics	passed	212.89 ms
  reads spans of any run length and skips every entry that pins nothing	register recipe semantics	passed	7.15 ms
  resolves the catalog's addresses on this corpus as written	address resolution and dependency cycles	passed	75.33 ms
  reports this corpus's dependency cycles as an independent reachability check finds them	address resolution and dependency cycles	passed	82.92 ms
  reports the probe's one set and one self-dependent Spec, and nothing for a Spec that only reaches a set	address resolution and dependency cycles	passed	6.38 ms
  reports a self-loop inside a larger set only with that set	address resolution and dependency cycles	passed	3.61 ms
  walks targets in code-unit order, so of two tied shortest cycles the first target's is reported	address resolution and dependency cycles	passed	2.43 ms
  walks a chain of 10,000 Specs and one cycle of 5,000 without recursing	address resolution and dependency cycles	passed	211.99 ms
  resolves an inherited property name only where the Spec authors it as a key	address resolution and dependency cycles	passed	4.43 ms
  resolves the design's probe addresses with one row and one reason each	address resolution and dependency cycles	passed	3.17 ms
  resolves a keyed question, refuses description in Design and UI, and keeps repeats	address resolution and dependency cycles	passed	9.75 ms
  registers a keyed question with its key and an unkeyed one with a null key	address resolution and dependency cycles	passed	3.09 ms
  audits a question address against the target's open question keys	address resolution and dependency cycles	passed	2.01 ms
  addresses a keyed question's text and matches its key, never the key as a row	address resolution and dependency cycles	passed	6.51 ms
  returns one row per Studio member with four independent facts	design references and the architecture taxonomy	passed	151.01 ms
  lists a referencing unit beside the realizing units without conferring implemented	design references and the architecture taxonomy	passed	177.28 ms
  lists the reader beside each Studio member that depends on it, with its realizing units	design references and the architecture taxonomy	passed	58.06 ms
  derives builds-on from the member's relations without conferring a fact on it	design references and the architecture taxonomy	passed	184.39 ms
  returns the role, layer, and context taxonomy from the code units alone	design references and the architecture taxonomy	passed	41.05 ms
  counts references as edges apart from the units that carry them	design references and the architecture taxonomy	passed	86.84 ms
  creates each taxonomy bucket once, however many units share the value	design references and the architecture taxonomy	passed	76.57 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 1	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.79 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 2	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.48 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 3	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.45 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 4	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.46 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 5	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.42 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 6	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.4 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 7	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.42 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 8	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.41 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 9	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.48 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 10	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.37 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 11	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.34 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 12	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.44 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 13	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.39 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 14	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.42 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 15	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.37 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 16	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.37 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 17	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.39 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 18	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.34 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 19	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.38 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 20	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.35 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 21	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.34 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 22	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.39 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 23	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.39 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 24	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.39 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 25	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.42 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 26	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.4 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 27	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.44 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 28	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.4 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 29	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.43 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 30	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.4 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 31	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.38 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 32	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.39 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 33	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.39 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 34	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.42 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 35	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.41 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 36	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.41 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 37	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.41 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 38	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.42 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 39	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.42 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 40	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.42 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 41	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.44 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 42	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.54 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 43	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.37 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 44	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.44 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 45	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.42 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 46	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.44 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 47	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.38 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 48	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.41 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 49	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.39 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 50	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.39 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 51	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.41 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 52	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.4 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 53	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.41 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 54	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.47 ms
  declares and checks only its indexed parameter names first: 55	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.42 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 1	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	51.01 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 2	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	52.58 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 3	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	100.63 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 4	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	91.08 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 5	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	47.65 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 6	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	43.57 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 7	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	58.12 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 8	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	51.43 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 9	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	39.48 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 10	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	39.28 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 11	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	38.46 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 12	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	35.14 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 13	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	30.1 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 14	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	24.97 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 15	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	49.06 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 16	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	34.98 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 17	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	40.63 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 18	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	47.48 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 19	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	32.12 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 20	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	29.38 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 21	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	35.4 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 22	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	35.22 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 23	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	30.44 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 24	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	44.73 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 25	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	35.84 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 26	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	35.92 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 27	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	37.36 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 28	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	34.43 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 29	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	37.29 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 30	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	34.53 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 31	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	37.03 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 32	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	36.83 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 33	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	32.3 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 34	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	35.47 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 35	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	29.61 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 36	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	24.05 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 37	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	26.88 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 38	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	27.56 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 39	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	36.86 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 40	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	35.16 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 41	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	37.01 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 42	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	35.48 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 43	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	37.25 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 44	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	33.94 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 45	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	36.1 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 46	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	35.61 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 47	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	36.31 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 48	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	37.58 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 49	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	35.48 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 50	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	53.29 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 51	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	27.25 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 52	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	36.52 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 53	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	38.97 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 54	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	36.76 ms
  returns only the unknown-name answer before reading recipe inputs: 55	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	36.94 ms
  diagnoses wrong subject names, mixed known names and ordered unknown names through shipped bodies	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	104.45 ms
  reads and names each parameter, with a fallback only when the contract supplies one	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	8.38 ms
  ships every catalog body as dist/recipes/NN-slug.js, byte for byte	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	8.03 ms
  runs every shipped file, read whole, to the answer its catalog body gives	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	6717.44 ms
  refuses a catalog whose bodies and headings do not pair, rather than guess a file name	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	1.71 ms
  reads a CRLF catalog as its LF bodies, and refuses a catalog with no recipe before publishing	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	17.69 ms
  removes only completed recipe files the catalog no longer owes, never another run's temporary file	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	0.66 ms
  passes recipe 4 its changed files from a file named with @PATH	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	44.98 ms
  resolves the addresses recipe 25 receives as data	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	58.78 ms
  reads the Pack the Pack recipes review from params.pack	recipe parameters and the shipped recipe files	passed	205.22 ms
  returns the Pack design of every corpus Pack as the raw graph states it	design recipes	passed	749.92 ms
  returns the probe Pack's design exactly, member by member	design recipes	passed	9.73 ms
  reaches every Spec resting on the corpus sample, by a shortest path of real edges	design recipes	passed	342.59 ms
  walks a dependency chain inbound only, once per Spec, and keeps a reference apart	design recipes	passed	1.76 ms
  registers every corpus decision with its supersession, subjects and keyed questions	design recipes	passed	71.82 ms
  registers a supersedes pair both ways and a decision that shapes nothing	design recipes	passed	1.4 ms
  carries a relation's reason beside the relation in recipes 3, 19, 21 and 31	design recipes	passed	1.56 ms
  registers narrowing decisions both ways and excludes refinement by other kinds	design recipes	passed	0.55 ms
  keeps the decoder in reader without adding crossings against the lawful notation alternative	design recipes	passed	125.17 ms
  reports the corpus's architecture crossings as the raw edges state them	design recipes	passed	70.26 ms
  names a crossing of two contexts and of two layers, and skips what cannot cross	design recipes	passed	0.79 ms
  resolves every keyed corpus entry to its value and the line the location table records	entry lines in entry search and address resolution	passed	179.39 ms
  gives each corpus entry-search row the line of a located entry and null otherwise	entry lines in entry search and address resolution	passed	173.89 ms
  never gives a nested entry the line of a literal top-level key its path spells	entry lines in entry search and address resolution	passed	3.85 ms
  counts a verifying Spec of another kind as a verifier, never as an example, in the Pack design	entry lines in entry search and address resolution	passed	2.27 ms
  gives a string-form open question the line its question[n] row records, as the object form	entry lines in entry search and address resolution	passed	2.46 ms
  counts equal layers and contexts between distinct components even without crossings	answers that fit	passed	0.36 ms
  returns guarantee entries and complete unit and verifier locations from context	answers that fit	passed	4.73 ms
  reports directions relative to an impacted Pack	answers that fit	passed	0.74 ms
  indexes exactly the present recipes with names, parameters and uses	answers that fit	passed	3.7 ms
  runs a shipped body wrapped inside a caller's filter	answers that fit	passed	98.75 ms
  keeps impact totals and puts both edge directions in the summary	answers that fit	passed	2.43 ms
  keeps the reader's Pack value in summary, full and selected-member answers	answers that fit	passed	11.46 ms
  reports both next rungs when the stated rung is below the floor	answers that fit	passed	0.56 ms
  reports no next rung at ready	answers that fit	passed	37.39 ms
  reports gap exemptions and every omitted warning beyond the first 25	answers that fit	passed	1.41 ms
  lists only defined unimplemented designs and keeps exclusions and references	answers that fit	passed	0.88 ms
  registers fields and counts deferrals apart from design holds	authoring grammar recipes	passed	3.39 ms
  lists intended mentions apart and preserves the validator's warnings	authoring grammar recipes	passed	8.29 ms
  matches rule keys beside their text without searching the derived map	authoring grammar recipes	passed	2.45 ms
  locates unkeyed rule text and question field text	authoring grammar recipes	passed	3.44 ms
  resolves rule addresses and preserves every parsed part of a miss	authoring grammar recipes	passed	2.85 ms
  counts rule coverage from bound examples and reports unbound intent beside it	authoring grammar recipes	passed	4.82 ms
  reports missing rule-coverage scopes and accepts a scope with no rules	authoring grammar recipes	passed	2.94 ms
  runs the catalog body in the evaluator without a module loader	entry citations recipe	passed	0.74 ms
  orders a declaration's citing files and lines independently of input order	entry citations recipe	passed	0.54 ms
  joins declarations and other cited entries, including uncited declarations	entry citations recipe	passed	0.69 ms
  includes absent Specs and malformed tokens only in the corpus unresolved list	entry citations recipe	passed	1.07 ms
  returns diagnostics without findings for {"pack":"pack:missing"}	entry citations recipe	passed	0.69 ms
  returns diagnostics without findings for {"specs":["spec:missing"]}	entry citations recipe	passed	0.42 ms
  returns diagnostics without findings for {"specs":"spec:probe.cited"}	entry citations recipe	passed	0.32 ms
  returns diagnostics without findings for {"pack":"pack:probe.citations","specs":[]}	entry citations recipe	passed	0.36 ms
  returns diagnostics without findings for {"severity":"fatal"}	entry citations recipe	passed	0.34 ms
  returns diagnostics without findings for {"severity":null}	entry citations recipe	passed	0.75 ms
  reads an absent table as empty, and accepts an empty Spec scope	entry citations recipe	passed	0.64 ms
  adds recorded component fields, references, member roles and exact crossing-use counts	Studio architecture and example-space recipe additions	passed	97.49 ms
  runs shipped recipe 44 over every decoded space and refuses bad scopes	Studio architecture and example-space recipe additions	passed	407.84 ms
  runs recipe 45 as shipped and reports missing and malformed CTRF metadata	not recorded	passed	535.5 ms
  recipe 49 renders the panel memo from its catalog body and refuses a malformed document	not recorded	passed	69.85 ms
  reports text-preserving rule and flow key changes apart from rewording	not recorded	passed	6.76 ms
  preserves a removed keyed rule address beside new unkeyed text	not recorded	passed	1.93 ms
  preserves a removed keyed flow address beside new unkeyed text	not recorded	passed	1.67 ms
  distinguishes removed unkeyed rule base positions from head positions	not recorded	passed	2.38 ms
  distinguishes removed unkeyed flow base positions from head positions	not recorded	passed	1.8 ms
  retains every diamond edge and intermediate node while counting each descendant once	the capability map recipe	passed	0.87 ms
  returns summary/full parity with explicit omissions for scope {}	the capability map recipe	passed	1.4 ms
  returns summary/full parity with explicit omissions for scope {"epic":"spec:probe.epic"}	the capability map recipe	passed	1 ms
  normalizes prose and unflagged questions while preserving authored indices	the capability map recipe	passed	0.35 ms
  retains null titles in serialized node and epic rows when a title degrades	the capability map recipe	passed	0.6 ms
  reports a self-refining epic as a cycle without making it its own parent epic	the capability map recipe	passed	0.3 ms
  uses the outside unreached parent as root rather than its child cycle group	the capability map recipe	passed	0.42 ms
  selects an epic of kind behavior without changing its kind	the capability map recipe	passed	0.4 ms
  selects an epic of kind workflow without changing its kind	the capability map recipe	passed	0.24 ms
  selects an epic of kind example without changing its kind	the capability map recipe	passed	0.22 ms
  selects an epic of kind rule without changing its kind	the capability map recipe	passed	0.2 ms
  selects an epic of kind constraint without changing its kind	the capability map recipe	passed	0.18 ms
  selects an epic of kind model without changing its kind	the capability map recipe	passed	0.18 ms
  selects an epic of kind decision without changing its kind	the capability map recipe	passed	0.19 ms
  selects an epic of kind contract without changing its kind	the capability map recipe	passed	0.2 ms
  reads node evidence and ordered questions directly, including examples and decisions as parents	the capability map recipe	passed	0.66 ms
  represents a missing floor as none and keeps the epic's evidence outside its rollup	the capability map recipe	passed	0.42 ms
  counts stated rungs separately from reached floors without lending a bound example's facts to its epic	the capability map recipe	passed	0.89 ms
  keeps nested and overlapping memberships and outside parents when selecting one epic	the capability map recipe	passed	1.07 ms
  traverses only declared refinement and never infers ancestry from other graph structure	the capability map recipe	passed	0.56 ms
  reports cycles, self-links and unresolved or non-Spec endpoints separately from parameter failures	the capability map recipe	passed	0.65 ms
  limits damage to edges touching a selected epic scope and terminates reached cycles	the capability map recipe	passed	0.44 ms
  keeps overlapping unreached root scopes unique and exposes an empty corpus	the capability map recipe	passed	0.52 ms
  refuses invalid parameters without a map: { epic: null }	the capability map recipe	passed	0.24 ms
  refuses invalid parameters without a map: { epic: 1 }	the capability map recipe	passed	0.14 ms
  refuses invalid parameters without a map: { epic: [] }	the capability map recipe	passed	0.1 ms
  refuses invalid parameters without a map: { epic: 'spec:probe.absent' }	the capability map recipe	passed	0.09 ms
  refuses invalid parameters without a map: { epic: 'spec:probe.plain' }	the capability map recipe	passed	0.09 ms
  refuses invalid parameters without a map: { epic: 'impl:probe.non-spec' }	the capability map recipe	passed	0.11 ms
  refuses invalid parameters without a map: { detail: 'true' }	the capability map recipe	passed	0.09 ms
  refuses invalid parameters without a map: { detail: 1 }	the capability map recipe	passed	0.09 ms
  refuses invalid parameters without a map: { detail: null }	the capability map recipe	passed	0.09 ms
  refuses invalid parameters without a map: { epic: 1, detail: 'x' }	the capability map recipe	passed	0.16 ms
  checks unknown names before known values	the capability map recipe	passed	0.15 ms
  answers deterministically in code-unit id order even when graph arrays are reversed	the capability map recipe	passed	1.41 ms
  reaches every Spec from the intended epic owners while preserving kinds and overlapping refinement	the Protocol's capability epics	passed	196.63 ms
  keeps refinement and dependency from spec:extraction.build-pipeline to spec:extraction.derive-graph	the Protocol's capability epics	passed	3.01 ms
  keeps refinement and dependency from spec:validation.corpus-rules to spec:consumers.agent-surface	the Protocol's capability epics	passed	4.22 ms
  keeps refinement and dependency from spec:validation.architecture-constraints to spec:validation.corpus-rules	the Protocol's capability epics	passed	3.84 ms
  keeps refinement and dependency from spec:validation.external-registers to spec:validation.corpus-rules	the Protocol's capability epics	passed	1.69 ms
  keeps every ready statement at the ready floor and leaves the drift alarm empty	the Protocol's capability epics	passed	63.69 ms
  runs the catalog body over the arc Pack through the CLI and keeps its summary totals	the shipped design slice	passed	322.71 ms
  runs the roadmap and its memo from the catalog over a named Pack	not recorded	passed	372.97 ms
  pins the adopter roadmap and its forward memo over the worked example	not recorded	passed	38.84 ms

Requirement drawing

• Declared verifying examples: no declared verifying example.

Decisions

No decision record named.

• impl:protocol.answer-shape-recipes · asserts realization of the catalog's compact and detailed answers · test/recipes.test.ts:6214

  Uses

  None.

Runtime observation: not tracked.

Runtime observation: not tracked.

Build attestations: not tracked.

Deployments: not tracked.

Bills of materials: not tracked.